Full menu
Box of Chocolate Chip Cuties (24)
$57.60
Soft, chewy cookies studded with rich chocolate chips. Box contains 24 pieces.
Surprise Me Gooey Pack (12 Cookies)
$84.00
This box is for the person who can't make up their mind. This assortment features a variety of our core and seasonal flavors, so you can enjoy a little bit of everything.
Box of Rainbow Crumbfetti Cuties (36)
$86.40
Soft and chewy cookies with colorful sprinkles throughout, offering a delightful burst of sweetness in every bite.
Box of Chocolate Chip Cuties (36)
Soft and chewy cookies packed with rich chocolate chips, available in a box of 36.
Surprise Me Gooey Pack (6 Cookies)
$42.00
Box of Chocolate Chip Cuties (12)
$28.80
Soft, chewy cookies studded with rich chocolate chips. Box includes 12 pieces.
S'mores
$8.00
These gooey, toasty cookies will bring your back to your childhood. Their chewy center is filled with crunchy graham crackers and topped with toasted marshmallows. They'll fix your s'mores craving without the campfire. "Heavenly", "Unlike no other", "Best cookie I've ever had". Ingredients:butter, flour, eggs, sugar, milk chocolate, golden grahams, marshmallows. All baked to order. We recommend warming the cookies at 350 degrees for three minutes!
Cookies n' Cream
These fudgey cookies have a brownie-like center and delicious, crispy edges. The combination of white chocolate morsels and chocolate cream cookie crumble base make for the most decadent cookie ever.
Box of Cookies N Cream Cuties (12)
Chunks of rich chocolate cookie dough mixed with creamy white chocolate pieces.
Crispy Mallow
There are no two ways about it: These cookies are the best of both worlds. They combine your favorite nostalgic cereal treat with a cookie with a big spoonful of your favorite soft and chewy marshmallows. Crunchy on the outside, chewy on the inside, and ready to melt in your mouth.
Gluten-Free Vegan Chocolate Chip
Our iconic chocolate chip cookie, hailed as the best in NYC, is now available in a vegan and gluten-free version. Perfectly crafted for those with dietary preferences or restrictions, these cookies deliver the same indulgent experience as our original. Each softball-sized cookie is a mound of chewy, chocolatey goodness that melts in your mouth, with a rich flavor and satisfying texture that will leave everyone asking for more. Made with plant-based butter and gluten-free ingredients, these cook
Box of Rainbow Crumbfetti Cuties (12)
Soft cookies studded with colorful sprinkles, offering a delightful burst of sweetness in every bite. Box includes twelve cookies.
Box of Rainbow Crumbfetti Cuties (24)
Soft and chewy cookies with colorful rainbow sprinkles, offering a delightful crunch in every bite.
Box of Cookies N Cream Cuties (36)
Rich chocolate cookies with creamy white chocolate chunks, offering a delightful contrast in texture and flavor. Box contains 36 cookies.
Box of Cookies N Cream Cuties (24)
Rich chocolate cookies with creamy white chocolate chunks, offering a delightful contrast in texture and flavor.
12 Pack of Courtside Cuties
$27.60
These Cuties are fun-sized versions of our fan favorite Gooey Cookies, dressed in blue and orange for game day. Even though these sweet snacks are smaller in size, they’re equally as delicious. The Courtside Cutie Pack comes ready to share in packs of 12, 24, or 36 — perfect for watch parties, celebrations, or stress eating during the fourth quarter.
NYC Soccer Club Pack
$66.70
Celebrate soccer season in NYC with our limited-edition NYC Soccer Club Pack! Inspired by the excitement of international football, New York City watch parties, and the energy surrounding the 2026 global soccer tournament, this collection combines our signature Gooey Cookies with sporty decorated sugar cookies perfect for game day celebrations, office parties, client gifting, and soccer fans alike. Whether you’re hosting a World Cup watch party in NYC or sending a sweet treat to your favorite soccer fan, this pack is the ultimate game day dessert spread. What's Included: 1 NYC Soccer Club Cookie, 1 Game On Soccer Ball Cookie, 4 Gooey Cookies
12 Pack of Coconut Macaroons
These Coconut Macaroons are a classic sweet treat with a soft, chewy center and perfectly toasted coconut on the outside. They come ready to share in packs of 12, 24, or 36 — perfect for gifting, dessert spreads, or keeping a stash for whenever a craving strikes. Designed to be shared or enjoyed all by yourself. Ingredients: Egg whites, Sweetened condensed milk, Shredded coconut, Salt, Vanilla. Please note: These cookies are made on the same equipment as gluten and dairy products and are not recommended for those with a gluten allergy.
Bag of Brown Butter Toffee Crisps
$6.00
These Brown Butter Toffee Crisps are thin, golden, and perfectly crunchy, with rich brown butter flavor and buttery toffee bits baked into every bite. They come ready to share in a 3oz. snackable packs — perfect for gifting, office treats, or keeping on hand whenever a craving strikes. Designed to be shared or enjoyed all by yourself. Ingredients: Flour, Butter, Brown butter extract, Brown Sugar, Sugar, Eggs, Salt, Toffee bits, Cereal, Vanilla.
New York Black & White Cookie
$7.00
Ingredients: AP flour, sugar, eggs, butter, lemon zest, milk, confectioners sugar, cocoa powder, corn syrup, corn starch, salt, vanilla
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Meet our Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie: a comforting classic done the Funny Face way. Soft, chewy, and packed with oats, this cookie strikes the perfect balance between wholesome texture and melty chocolate in every bite. Ingredients: Butter, Flour, Oats, Eggs, Sugar, Cinnamon, Maple Syrup, Milk Chocolate Chips
Deluxe Chocolate Chip
Our deluxe six-ounce chocolate chip cookies aren't any ordinary cookie - they're softball-sized mounds of deliciousness. Their ooey-gooey molten center melts in your mouth and is bound to fix all of your sweet tooth cravings. "Truly the best cookie I've ever had". "Too good to be legal". "Nothing compares, best cookie in NYC hands down." Ingredients: butter, flour, eggs, sugar, semi-sweet and milk chocolate. We recommend warming the cookies at 350 degrees for three minutes!
Rainbow Crumbfetti
These treats have the same sweet taste as the originals but with a colorful twist. You'll be transported to your childhood with every bite. When you're in the mood to celebrate - celebrate with sprinkles.
Happy Birthday!
$17.25
Brightly colored cookie with "Happy Birthday!" message in rainbow icing.
Let's Pawdy!
Dog-themed cookie decorated with colorful balloons and the phrase "let's pawdy!"
Greetings from NY!
A rectangular cookie with colorful "Greetings from New York City" icing, featuring a cityscape background.
Pizza Rat
A cookie shaped like a rat holding a slice of pizza, decorated with detailed icing.
The Big Apple
A sugar cookie shaped and decorated as a vibrant red apple with "New York City" written in yellow icing.
You are magical
A unicorn-shaped cookie adorned with colorful icing, featuring the phrase "You are Magical" in vibrant detail.
You're The MVP
Create quality memories and show appreciation by sending these personalized cookie gifts made for everyone! Find a perfect gift for the ones you love. Our decorated sugar cookies are expertly curated for Mom, Dad, coworkers, your boyfriend, girlfriend, friends, or even for yourself. Visit one of our NYC locations or ship them nationwide—we’ll deliver them straight to your doorstep! If you need to place a bulk order, please email [email protected]!
Game On
Happy Father's Day
Bl*w me
A cookie shaped like a slice of cake, decorated with pink icing, white frosting details, and blue letters spelling "BLOW ME."
City Slicker
A rectangular cookie decorated to resemble a city metro card, with yellow, blue, and black icing details.
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: