Full menu
Special Toppings
$0.50
$25 charge for advent calendar
$25.00
Includes a selection of sweet treats, typically arranged in a festive advent calendar format for daily enjoyment.
$25 charge for advent kits
$25 Charge for Advent Kits: A festive kit typically including assorted seasonal treats and small gifts, perfect for counting down the days to a special occasion.
18 oz fluff
$6.00
Add a second cup to your 24 Day Advent
$50.00
Add a second cup of ice cream to your 24 Day Advent Calendar.
Button
$1.00
A sweet, bite-sized dessert typically featuring a soft, delicate texture, often enjoyed as a classic treat reminiscent of traditional, homemade confections.
Fluff Topping
Light and airy, this fluff topping typically includes whipped marshmallow or cream, adding a sweet and smooth finish to any dessert.
GF CONE
Gracie's Fanny Pack!
$9.25
If you have to ask why you need a fanny pack, this fanny pack isn't for you, but just in case here are two reasons: 1) Your pockets are too small. 2) Even worse you don't have any pockets. A third reason is because when we ordered Gracie's sweatpants we decided a draw string was more important than pockets and we stand by that decision.
Gracie's and Earnest Drink Trucker Hat
$15.00
Gracie's trucker hats are back to keep your head shaded and let your pals find you in a crowd. Neon for full effect. Logo by the handsome, tall, and talented illustrator, Josh LaFayette.
Ice Cream Cup
$6.50
A scoop of our original ice cream in a cup.
Ice Cream Pint Koozie
$3.50
You're sitting on the couch with a pint in your hand and your hand is just freezing because you're eating ice cream just holding the pint in your bare hands because people don't wear gloves inside, but we made ice cream weather flamingo pint koozies just for you.
Ice Cream Weather Sweatpants
$25.75
Gracie’s Ice Cream Weather sweatpants are the perfect accompaniment to this season of your discontent, I mean isolation. You know what sweatpants are. This purchase is for in store pick up.
Lactaid
No Spoons No Masters T Shirt
Single color (pink) design on a black ring spun cotton t-shirt. I don't know what Ring Spun is, but it's supposed to be much softer than our soft shirts normally are.
Pink Flamingo Lawn Ornament
$10.00
You need a plastic yard flamingo? We've got plastic yard flamingoes for you. You can pick one up and bring it home.
Stanley Ice Cream
Stone & Skillet Pizza Night
$14.00
The Dinner at Gracie's series continues during our reopening weekend feature the fantastic muffin men from Stone & Skillet on January 21! Dinner will feature muffin pizzas on Stone & Skillet muffins along with a bread pudding dessert with a scoop of ice cream. Ticketing will be staggered again between 5 and 8 pm so it doesn't get crazy crazy crowded.
Union Square Semi-Formal
The semi-formal. The highlight of any middle school year. Who doesn't have fond memories of middle school? Well, probably everyone. In any case, the Union Square Semi-Formal is Saturday February, 11th from 3-6PM, and includes stops at 4 different businesses. Your ticket includes an ice cream from Gracie's, along with special drink selections at Juliet, The Independent, and Brass Union! Since it's a Semi-Formal, we'll of course be playing your favorite music from middle school dances. And since it's a Semi-Formal, semi-formal attire is suggested. Go with a group of friends, or ask your sweetheart, this is the Semi-Formal and it doesn't matter who you go with, you just have to show up. Attendees will start at Gracie's and Juliet and then head over to The Indo and Brass Union. More details soon!
TACOS
$7.00
2 shirts for $20
$20.00
Two custom-designed items for $20, typically including t-shirts, mugs, or tote bags featuring ice cream-themed illustrations or logos.
Closest Thing To Love T Shirt
Single color (white) design on a dark grey ring spun cotton t-shirt. I don't know what Ring Spun is, but it's supposed to be much softer than our soft shirts normally are.
Defend Ice Cream t shirt
Order online at graciesicecre.am. This is for in store pick up only.
Die Hard ornament
Don't Melt on Me T-Shirt
Black and yellow Don't Melt On Me t-shirt. Loose fit sizing only. Order online at graciesicecre.am. This is for in store pick up only.
Eclipse glasses
$4.00
Get a cone you coward.
Get an ice cream cone, you coward heather red t-shirt. Loose fit sizing only. Order online at graciesicecre.am. This is for in store pick up only.
Gracie's Bandana
22"x22" black or red bandana to use as a bandana on your head, in your hair, as a face covering, or for your dog or cat or alligator. We have discounted the bandanas from $7.50 to $3.50 because of a design issue on some of the bandanas. They're mostly fine, and you might not even notice, but if I sent them back to the printer, they'd just get thrown out.
Gracie's Cone Umbrella shirt
1 color screen print designed by artist Lauren May / Monster Tea Party. When it turns it churns. Order online at graciesicecre.am. This is for in store pick up only.
Ice Cream Weather Tank Top
Ice Cream Weather front, “The closest thing to love that this country has to offer” on the back. Unisex tank top design for max comfort.
More For Your Freezer Gracie's hoodie
$30.00
Black comfort hoodie with two color Josh LaFayette design. Arriving in stock March 16th.
Never Say Vanilla (Goonie's Tribute)
Single color (white) design on a black ring spun cotton t-shirt. I don't know what Ring Spun is, but it's supposed to be much softer than our soft shirts normally are. Design by Jess Frease.
Out of Step T-Shirt
Gracie’s Out of Step two color design on aqua t-shirt. Illustrated by Jessica Frease.
Salty Avocado children's book
$11.00
The first children's book from Gracie's owner Aaron Cohen. The Salty Avocado is a children's book about a truly rotten fruit who finds redemption in the healing power of raspberry hugs. The book features Chris Piascik's vibrant illustrations and style-defining lettering matched with Aaron Cohen's playful and endearing story. This book is for kids who like big colors and catchy words, but it's also for parents who end up reading the same story every single night. (This is every parent.) The Salty Avocado wasn't always so salty, in fact, he used to be one of the more popular members of his home in the fridge. Then one day, an accident changed him. It wasn't his fault, but after that day Avocado's mood turned dark and there wasn't anything any of his food friends could do. Little by little the other foods desserted (get it?) him. Soon he was all alone and liked it that way. Can anything change Avocado back to his gregarious self? With whimsical rhymes and rousing illustrations, The Sa...
Soccer cards
Collectible soccer-themed cards, ideal for fans and enthusiasts.
Something Good T Shirt
Single color (white) design on a gray ring spun cotton t-shirt. I don't know what Ring Spun is, but it's supposed to be much softer than our soft shirts normally are.
Staff Apparel
Sticker
T Shirt
$18.00
Tiny Animal Friends
$0.70
Whether you need just an individual tiny flamingo friend or an entire flamboyance of tiny flamingo friends, Gracie's has got you covered. These little pink pals are about an inch and we've got a whole bag of them. We've also got dragons, T-Rex, penguin, alligators, and manatees!
Hats
Gracie’s Ice Cream Hats, pink, orange, and yellow available
Onesie
$17.00
12 month Gracie's onesie with Lauren May's cone umbrella art.
1 Scoop Sundae
$4.50
Argenziano Token
$4.85
Cone Token 5 Pack
$24.00
Each of these handy-dandy gift bags includes 5 tokens worth one free ice cream cone each at Gracie's.
Fest cone ($6.50)
Fest plus $1 ($7.50)
$7.50
Fest waffle ($8.50)
$8.50
Fluff Cone (select only one flavor)
One scoop of ice cream on a Fluff Cone, tax included.
Fluff fest cone
Fluff fest waffle
Grape push pop
Grape ice cream in a convenient push pop typically includes a blend of grape flavor and creamy texture for a refreshing treat.
Half Pints
Halloween sandwiches
Ice Cream Flight
$13.00
This is a taste of everything we've got. It works out to be about 6 regular-sized scoops of ice cream. Feel free to share it or not.
Ice Cream Pie
$28.50
These 9 inch pies are intended for you to eat whenever you want or during a special occasion. They feed 6-12 people depending on the size of your slice and you should remove the pie 10ish minutes before you'd like to serve it so it can be cut. If you don't see something you like, get in touch and we might be able to make it happen.
Ice Cream Truck Novelty
$3.25
Ice cream
$3.95
Ice cream cups and cones
$4.45
We're trying this way of ordering/paying for cones at the moment to minimize interaction between staff and customers. You're welcome to order ahead and announce yourself when you arrive, at which point we'll scoop for you.
Kid
Kiddie
$3.85
$0.75
Lamplighter pop tart
Large
$5.85
$6.65
Personal Non - Dairy Cup
Pie and Pint
$32.00
Pints to Take Home
Choose your flavor and pick up your pint!
Pop tart plus fluff
$8.00
Ice cream infused with pieces of pop tart and swirls of marshmallow fluff.
Six Scoop Flight
Small
$5.65
Sundae
$6.25
Sundae party
Treats
aeronaut pop tart
Sundae Party Kit
$27.00
Two pint of ice cream, a can of whipped cream, some M&Ms, some Oreos, and sprinkles. This is about 6-8 sundaes.
To Go Toppings
$1.50
Fluff Cone/Cup Topping
$1.35
Specialty Cone
Sprinkles
Waffle Cone
Waffle Fluff
$2.50
Whipped Cream
Dipped Cones
$1.25
Fudge
Soda
$2.00
Frappe
Tea
$3.00
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: