Full menu
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$16.80
Mustardy chicken, pickled red onion, lettuce, potato chips, & mustard mayo on sliced challah
Best Bialy
Hot & Cold smoked salmon salad, dill & caper schmear, & pickled red onion on an onion bialy
Schnitzel Sandwich
$18.90
Fried chicken thighs, dilly cukes, pickled cabbage, & hot honey mayo on sliced challah
Pastrami on Rye
$22.05
8 oz of house smoked beef pastrami with deli mustard on Rye
Reuben Sandwich
Your choice of homemade beef, turkey, or tofu pastrami with sauerkraut, swiss, & russian dressing on rye
Yenta Bagel
Whitefish salad, scallion schmear, & pickled peppers on an everything bagel
Broccoli Caesar Sandwich
$14.70
Our broccoli kale caesar salad...on a sandwich! With a smoky tofu schmear, red onion, a touch of hot sauce & some potato chips on sourdough rye
Tuna Salad Sandwich
$15.75
Smoked tuna salad on your choice of bagel. With lettuce, tomato, dilly cukes, sun-dried tomato schmear, and dijonaise.
Egg & Cheese
$12.60
2 eggs, cheddar, pickled peppers, & GERTIE hot sauce on a bagel or bialy
Bagel & Schmear
$5.25
Your choice of bagel OR bialy with schmear, smoked fish, & as many fixins as you want!
Vegan Broccoli Ceasar
Our take on a Caesar salad with roasted broccoli, kale, sesame seeds, pickled peppers, & a creamy VEGAN dressing with lemon & nutritional yeast
Greek-ish Salad
A GERTIE Classic! Arugula, dilly cukes, cherry tomato, olive, feta, wax beans, dill & preserved lemon vinaigrette
Scoop Salad
Little gem, dilly cukes, pickled red onions, seasonal veggies, hard boiled egg, house vinaigrette, & deli salad scoop of choice
COLD Matzo Ball Soup (quart)
Chicken bone broth, carrot, onion, dill, mustardy chicken, & matzoh balls
Latkes
$9.45
3 Potato Pancakes served with your choice of toppings (all toppings served on the side)
Brown Butter CC Rye Cookie
A perfectly not-too sweet chocolate chip cookie made with brown butter and rye flour!
Orange Almond Poppy Cake
$6.30
Orange juice, orange zest, & almond flour round out this scrumptiously delicious, perfectly sweet GF cake
Black & White Cookie
From Green's Bakery, one of the oldest and most famous bakeries in NYC
Chocolate Babka
$8.40
Layers of chocolate & buttery pastry rolled into a delectable loaf
Honey Corn Muffin
Our famous corn muffin brushed with honey butter
Half Dozen Bagels
Choice of 6 bagels. Please note that Gluten Free bagels are served frozen (unless ordered on a bagel sandwich) & should be toasted before eating.
Full Dozen Bagels
$31.50
Choice of 12 bagels. Please note that Gluten Free bagels are served frozen (unless ordered on a bagel sandwich) & should be toasted before eating.
Espresso Drinks
$4.50+
Selection of espresso-based drinks. Choose from classic and contemporary varieties, served hot or iced with customizable milk and espresso options, including decaf and extra shots.
Egg Cream Latte
A Brooklyn classic! Chocolate OR Black Cherry Vanilla syrup with your choice of milk & seltzer
Shot Espresso
$4.20
Columbia Los Angeles beans from Parlor Coffee
Nitro Cold Brew
12oz of our house-brewed cold Brew made with Parlor's Prospect bean blend
Drip
Wallabout blend from Parlor Coffee
Chai Latte
By Spirit Tea Company
DRAFT Arnold Palmer
Half lemonade & half black tea by Spirit Tea Company
Lemonade
Made to order with Natalie's fresh lemon juice
Iced Tea
Your choice of iced tea from Spirit Tea Co. Black or Herbal
Matcha Latte
Hot Chocolate
Made with Fox's U-bet chocolate sauce & your choice of milk
Iced Oat Matcha on Tap
$7.35
Our house made Matcha Latte on Nitro draft! Made with oat milk & a little honey
Hot Tea
Lovely Bunch Apple Juice (8oz CAN)
Cloudy apple juice made from heirloom apples.
Loop Mission Juice (10oz BTL)
Cucumber, celery, spinach, kale, lemon, and ginger blend in a cold-pressed juice.
Ronnybrook Chocolate Milk (12oz BTL)
$3.15
Rich chocolate milk from Ronnybrook, offering a creamy, smooth texture in a 12-ounce bottle.
Natalie's OJ (12oz BTL)
Freshly squeezed orange juice, made with organic oranges, in a 12oz bottle. Contains no preservatives or added ingredients.
Natalie's Blood OJ (12oz BTL)
Freshly squeezed blood orange juice in a 12-ounce bottle.
Mountain Valley Still Water (10oz BTL)
Natural spring water sourced from the Mountain Valley, offered in a 10-ounce bottle.
Strange Water Coconut Water (12oz CAN)
$5.51
All-natural coconut water in a 12oz can.
Mountain Valley Sparkling Water (10oz BTL)
Effervescent sparkling water sourced from the Mountain Valley, presented in a 10-ounce bottle.
Orangina (12oz CAN)
Sparkling orange beverage with pulp from concentrate, served in a 12oz can.
Culture Pop Lemon Lime (12oz CAN)
Probiotic soda with lemon and lime flavors, offering a refreshing citrus taste in a 12oz can.
Dr. Browns Diet Cream (12oz CAN)
A 12oz can of Dr. Brown's diet cream soda, offering a classic soda experience with zero sugar.
Dr. Brown's Root Beer (12oz CAN)
Classic root beer with a rich, full-bodied flavor, served in a 12oz can.
BKE Kombucha (12oz CAN)
Cherry blossom and bergamot flavors blend in this limited edition kombucha.
Tepache Tropical Punch
A modern Mexican soda with a tropical fruit blend, featuring the traditional fermented flavor of tepache.
Diet Coke (8oz BTL)
Sugar-free cola with a crisp, refreshing taste, served in an 8-ounce bottle.
Coke (8oz BTL)
Classic Coca-Cola in an 8-ounce bottle, offering its signature blend of carbonated water, caramel color, and natural flavors.
Aplos NA Margarita (8oz CAN)
A non-alcoholic margarita featuring citrus flavors and a hint of chili, crafted for a refreshing cocktail experience.
NA Gut Feeling (375ml BTL)
Seedlip spice, beet, apple, carrot, ginger, lemon, and tonic blend into a vibrant non-alcoholic cocktail, offering a refreshing and unique flavor profile.
House Soda
Choose from our house made sodas with seltzer ON TAP!
Schmear (Cup)
Plain, Giardiniera, Scallion, or Dill & Caper!
Dilly Cukes (Cup)
Crisp cucumber slices marinated in tangy dill brine.
Side of Pickles
$2.10
Crunchy and tangy pickles, typically made from cucumbers, offering a classic taste that complements any meal.
Dills (Quart)
A quart (32oz) of our dill pickles
Pickled Peppers (Cup)
A cup (8oz) of our pickled peppers. Featured in our Egg & Cheese, Yenta, & Turkey Club sandwiches!
Smoked Tuna Salad (8oz Cup)
House-smoked tuna salad made with celery, capers, aioli, & mustard
Chicken Salad (8oz Cup)
House-roasted chicken salad made with mustard & celery
Hot & Cold Smoked Salmon (8oz Cup)
A cup (8oz) of our hot & cold smoked salmon salad! Half lox & half in-house-smoked salmon pastrami!
Acme Lox (3oz Packet)
4oz of Acme's famous lox
Whitefish Salad (8oz Cup)
House-smoked whitefish salad made with lemon zest, scallions, & mayo
Tofu Pastrami (1/2 LB)
A 1/2# of our famous tofu pastrami, smoked in-house!
Beef Pastrami (1/2 LB)
$21.00
A 1/2# of our famous beef pastrami, smoked in-house!
Turkey Pastrami (1/2 LB)
A 1/2# of our famous turkey pastrami, smoked in-house!
GERTIE Bloody Mary Mix (8oz BTL)
A blend of tomato juice, spices, and typically includes Worcestershire sauce and hot sauce, creating a classic base for crafting your own Bloody Mary cocktail.
North Fork Sour Cream & Onion
Crispy potato chips seasoned with tangy sour cream and savory onion flavor.
North Fork Potato Chips
Crispy kettle-cooked potato chips made from select potatoes, offering a satisfying crunch.
Zapps Voodoo
Kettle-style potato chips with a unique blend of spicy, sweet, and tangy flavors.
Zapps Cajun Dill
Crispy kettle-cooked potato chips seasoned with a tangy Cajun dill flavor, offering a unique New taste.
GERTIE Hat
$42.00
BwB Shirt
A comfortable and versatile shirt typically featuring a unique logo design, perfect for casual wear.
Spree
$2.62
Colorful, tangy hard candy with a sweet, fruity flavor and a crunchy shell.
Pop Rocks Cherry
$1.58
Effervescent candy crystals that crackle and pop with a bold cherry flavor.
Choward's Guava
Sweet guava-flavored candy offering a tropical taste in each piece.
Choward's Violet
Delicate violet-flavored candies, offering a unique floral taste in each piece.
Rolo
Caramel-filled chocolate cups typically encased in a milk chocolate shell.
DumDum Lollipop
$0.26
Assorted fruit-flavored lollipops with a hard candy shell on a stick.
Zero Chocolate Bar
A Zero chocolate bar typically features a blend of caramel, peanut, and almond nougat enrobed in a smooth white chocolate coating.
Swizzels Chews
These chewy candies typically include a variety of sweet and fruity flavors, offering a delightful treat that satisfies your sweet tooth with every bite.
Pocky
$1.31
Crispy biscuit sticks coated in a sweet, creamy layer.
Big Cherry Bar
A big cherry bar typically features milk chocolate filled with a cherry-flavored center, offering a sweet and fruity experience in every bite.
Cracker Jack
Caramel-coated popcorn and peanuts, offering a classic sweet and crunchy treat that's synonymous with nostalgic snacking moments.
B&W Pretzels
Hand-twisted pretzels, typically dipped in a blend of white and dark chocolate, offering a delightful combination of sweet and salty flavors.
5th Avenue Bar
$3.94
Crunchy peanut butter candy with a rich chocolate coating.
Margarita
No Sleep
Spritz
Martini
Rum
Vodka
Mezcal
Tequila
Whiskey
Scotch
Dirty Gertie
Negroni
Coke
Diet Coke
Cranberry Juice
Seltzer
Iced Black Tea
Iced Herbal Tea
Black Cherry soda
Cel-Ray
PIlsner
IPA
Marsanne
Chilled Red
Pais
Cava
Albarino
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: