Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

Assorted Bakers Dozen

$39.00

Please list in the special instructions your choice of cookies from the options listed below (13 total)

Assorted Half Dozen

$19.50

Please list in the special instructions your choice of cookies from the options listed below (6 total)

Confetti

$3.90

Our sugar cookie, made 80% more fun with sprinkles! Tastes like a birthday party.

Vegan Chocolate chip

$3.90

The Captain churns our vegan butter from scratch - these cookies are a three-day process, and their amazing taste is the result of years of recipe-tweaking!

Oatmeal Raisin

$3.90

The classic. Chewy oats with just the right level of spice and a generous helping of plump raisins.

Peanut Butter

$3.90

Our special twist on the classic peanut butter - it's gooey, with honey vanilla notes, and chock full of peanut butter!

Snickerdoodle

$3.90

Guaranteed to take you back to childhood with one bite. Our snickerdoodles are buttery, tender, and rolled in cinnamon sugar, just like Mom did.

Double Chocolate

$3.90

Our version of the chocolate lover's classic is rich, fudgy, and loaded with dark chocolate.

Gluten Friendly Cookie Pack (2 Cookies)

$6.50

Freshly baked and handmade, this gluten-friendly chocolate chip cookie delivers classic chewy goodness in every bite.

Chocolate Chip

$3.90

This is how it all started. The Captain has been perfecting the recipe for these rich, chewy cookies studded with dark chocolate chips for over 20 years.

Ginger Molasses

$3.90

Chewy, puffy cookies with dark molasses flavor, spiced with cloves, cinnamon, and lots of ginger. Crowned with sugar for a crispy crust!

Single Scoop

$7.80

Enjoy our delicious ice cream, sourced from a local creamery for the perfect creamy, flavorful treat. Pairs perfectly with our fresh-baked cookies!

Ice Cream Sandwich

$13.00

Our famous sandwich - choose any two cookies and ice cream!

Double Scoop

$11.70

Enjoy our delicious ice cream, sourced from a local creamery for the perfect creamy, flavorful treat. Pairs perfectly with our fresh-baked cookies!

Cookies + Milk

$10.40

2 Cookies and local milk

Milkshake

$13.00

Combine the best ice cream and milk from local creameries for a delightful treat! We offer chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry, as well as the occasional special if you stop by to see us.

Local Milk

$3.90

Our selection of 12 oz milk comes from local dairy South Mountain Creamery. Fresh from the farm to you, for the perfect companion to our made-from-scratch cookies!