The Bagel Mill

Select your bagel

$3.54

build your own bagel sandwich here. All bagels are sliced and toasted (unless noted otherwise). For a bagel and cream cheese, please select a spread. For bagels not sliced or toasted, please go to the 'Bagels To Go' section.

California Egg & Cheese

$15.34

organic egg, yellow cheddar, thick cut bacon, smashed avocado, tomato

Classic Lox Open

$18.88

cream cheese, 2 oz salmon lox, red onion, capers, fresh dill (served open-faced)

Classic Lox Closed

$13.57

cream cheese, 1 oz salmon lox, red onion, capers, fresh dill

Cream Cheese & Greens

$11.80

scallion cream cheese, radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, sprouts

Frittata Sandwich

$16.52

seasonal veggie frittata, smashed avocado, melted yellow cheddar

Bodega Egg & Cheese

$8.85

organic egg, yellow cheddar

Avocado Toast

$14.16

smashed avocado, lemon vinaigrette, pickled red onion, scallions, sprouts, everything mix (served open-faced)

Spicy Turkey Club

$18.88

smoked turkey, thick cut bacon, Monterey jack, avocado, tomato, lettuce, sriracha mayo

Pastrami Reuben

$18.29

pastrami, melted swiss, sauerkraut, russian dressing

Vegan Dream

$15.34

house made cashew cheese, roasted bell pepper, pickled red onion, cucumber, radish, smashed avocado, sprouts

The Jorge Special

$15.93

smoked turkey, sauteed bell pepper, red onion, jalapenos, melted swiss, sriracha mayo

Ham, Swiss & Honey Butter Sandwich

$15.34

black forest ham, melted swiss, salted honey butter, arugula

Egg Salad Sandwich

$12.39

organic egg salad, butter lettuce, chopped scallions

Tuna Salad Sandwich

$12.98

albacore tuna mixed with mildly spicy Sriracha mayo, celery & onions. Served with butter lettuce and tomato

Mitch's Vegan Seitan Sandwich Special

$16.52

house-made seitan (contains wheat and soy), sundried tomato pesto (vegan, contains walnuts), avocado, pickled red onion, arugula

Classic Bagel Burger Special

$16.52

1/3 lb. all beef patty, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, ketchup, mustard

BLAT

$15.34

thick cut bacon, butter lettuce, smashed avocado, tomato, mayo

Breakfast Bagel Burger Special

$22.42

1/3 lb. all beef patty cheeseburger, plus a bacon egg & cheese

Straus Yogurt & Granola

$8.26

organic Straus whole milk yogurt (unsweetened) & housemade granola

Side of Frittata

$8.26

seasonal veggie frittata served warm with arugula

Overnight Oats

$4.72

organic oats soaked overnight, honey, cinnamon

Simple Green Salad (Side)

$5.90

butter lettuce, arugula, watermelon radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, & lemon vinaigrette

Whole Dill Pickle

$3.54

1 large kosher dill pickle

Simple Green Salad (Large)

$10.62

butter lettuce, arugula, watermelon radish, cucumber, pickled red onions, & lemon vinaigrette

Fresh Fruit Salad

$8.26

an assortment of fresh fruit

Lay's Potato Chips

$2.36

Crispy Lay's potato chips. Choose from Classic, Sour Cream & Onion, BBQ.

Sun-dried Tomato Cream Cheese 1/2 pint

$10.62

Rich and creamy blend of sun-dried tomatoes and cream cheese, offering a savory spread perfect for bagels or sandwiches.

Plain Bagel Dog (Sunday 6/21 only!)

$10.03

all beef hot dog wrapped in sourdough bagel dough, then boiled & baked. Available for Father's Day Only!

Jalapeno Cheddar Bagel Dog (Sunday 6/21 only!)

$10.62

all beef hot dog wrapped in sourdough bagel dough, then boiled & baked. Available Father's Day Only!

Pecan Bacon Sticky Bun (Sunday 6/21 only)

$7.08

Father's Day special on 6/21!

Curry & Caramelized Onion 1/2 pint

$10.62

curry powder, sweet caramelized onions & a touch of sun-dried tomatoes

Roasted Strawberry Cream Cheese 1/2 pint

$10.62

organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm slow roasted with sugar

Challah Six Strand Loaf (Friday pre-orders only!)

$18.88

Six strand challah made with organic ingredients. Hybrid recipe with sourdough starter and instant yeast (dairy free)

Plain Bagel

$3.54

Golden-brown bagel with a chewy texture and a crisp crust.

Pizza Bagel

$4.72

Topped with melted cheese and tomato sauce, this bagel combines classic pizza flavors on a chewy, golden-brown base.

Everything Bagel

$3.54

Coated with a blend of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and salt, this bagel offers a savory and crunchy bite.

Cinnamon Raisin Bagel

$3.54

A chewy bagel with hints of cinnamon and sweet raisins baked into a golden crust.

Gluten Free Bagel

$4.72

from Mamamel's Bread in Petaluma

Sesame Bagel

$3.54

A chewy, golden-brown bagel topped with a generous layer of toasted sesame seeds.

Onion Bagel

$3.54

Toasted bagel with a crisp exterior, topped with caramelized onion bits.

Black Pepper Parmesan Bagel (Mon only!)

$4.72

a weekly special that is only available Mondays

Marble Rye Bagel

$3.54

Swirled with light and dark rye dough, this marble rye bagel offers a hearty texture and rich flavor.

Poppy Seed Bagel

$3.54

A golden-brown bagel generously coated with crunchy poppy seeds.

Whole Wheat Everything Bagel

$3.54

Topped with a blend of seeds, spices, and grains, this whole wheat bagel offers a hearty, nutty flavor.

Marble Rye Everything Bagel (Sat only!)

$3.54

a weekly special bagel that is only available on Saturdays

Salt Bagel (Sun only!)

$3.54

a weekly special that is only available Sundays

Pesto Bagel

$4.72

contains nuts (walnuts)

Asiago Bagel (Weds only!)

$4.72

a weekly special that is only available Wednesdays

Jalapeño Cheddar Bagel (Thurs only!)

$4.72

a weekly special bagel that is only available on Thursdays

Garlic Bagel

$3.54

A freshly baked bagel infused with garlic, offering a savory twist on a classic favorite.

Whole Wheat Bagel

$3.54

Made with whole wheat flour, this bagel offers a hearty texture and rich, nutty flavor.

Asiago Everything Bagel (Tues only!)

$4.72

a weekly special that is only available Tuesdays

Bialy (Fri only!)

$4.72

a weekly special bialy with caramelized onions and poppy seeds that is only available on Fridays

Challah Roll (Fri Only!)

$5.90

A traditional Jewish bread with a soft, pillowy texture and slightly sweet flavor, typically featuring a braided shape and golden-brown crust.

1 Dozen Bagels

$37.76

Please allow 48 hours notice for orders over 2 dozen.

1/2 Dozen Bagels

$20.06

Please allow 48 hours notice for orders over 2 dozen.

Salmon Lox (4 oz)

$21.24

4 oz of our premium smoked salmon lox from Santa Barbara Smokehouse

Plain Cream Cheese (1/2 pint)

$7.08

8 oz of cream cheese, serves 4-6 people

Single Serving (2 oz)

$1.77

2 oz portion of various spreads including cream cheese varieties, almond butter, strawberry jam, vegan cashew cheese, and more.

Tuna Salad (1/2 pint)

$12.98

8 oz of our albacore tuna salad with Sriracha mayo, red onion & celery

Vegan Spreads (1/2 pint)

$11.21

Vegan.

Egg Salad (1/2 pint)

$11.80

8 oz of our house made organic egg salad

Flavored Cream Cheese (1/2 pint)

$8.85

8 oz of our house made flavored cream cheeses & spreads, serves 4-6 people

Dark Chocolate Rye Rugelach

$3.54

Buttery, flaky dough filled with rich dark chocolate and rye, typically includes hints of cinnamon and sugar for a delightful treat.

Walnut Cinnamon Rugelach

$3.54

Cinnamon, walnuts & raisin filling. Sold individually.

Pecan Bacon Sticky Bun (Sunday 6/21 only)

$7.08

Father's Day special on 6/21!

Chocolate Oat Cookie (Gluten Free)

$5.90

made with gluten free oat flour (but made in our kitchen which is NOT gluten free)

Almond Matcha Tea Cake with Strawberry Glaze

$7.08

matcha cake with Stony Point strawberry glaze. For Mother's Day Pick Up!

Latte

$5.90

Rich espresso combined with steamed milk. Available in 8 oz, 12 oz, and 16 oz sizes. Choose from a variety of milk options like Whole, 1%, Oat, Almond, Soy, and Coconut.

Mocha

$7.38

Rich blend of coffee and chocolate. Choose size. Variety of milk options available. Optional house-made whipped cream.

Drip Coffee

$4.13

Drip coffee, available in 8 oz, 12 oz, and 16 oz sizes. Choice of cream, black, or various milk options like 1%, almond, coconut, oat, soy, half & half, or whole milk.

Cappuccino

$5.90

Rich espresso with frothy milk. Choose from a variety of milk options including whole, 1%, oat, almond, soy, and more.

White Chocolate Mocha

$7.38

Whole, 1%, breve, oat, almond, soy, or coconut. Optional house-made whipped cream.

Espresso

$4.72

Rich, concentrated coffee shot with a robust flavor and a smooth, velvety crema on top.

Macchiato

$5.02

Double shot of espresso with a dollop of milk foam

Gibraltar

$5.31

Whole, 1%, breve, oat, almond, soy, or coconut.

Americano

$4.72

Bold and strong coffee with customizable sizes and options for different milk preferences or plain black.

Cafe au Lait

$4.72

8 oz, 12 oz, 16 oz. Milk choices include dairy, oat, almond, soy, and coconut.

Brown Butter Latte

$7.08

house-made syrup made with brown butter

Strawberry Matcha Latte

$7.96

made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm

Horchata Latte

$7.08

house-made syrup made with soaked rice and cinnamon sticks

Iced Strawberry Horchata Chai Latte

$9.44

organic strawberry & horchata syrups

Strawberry Lemonade

$6.49

Refreshing blend of strawberry and lemonade. Available in 12 or 16 oz sizes.

Strawberry Latte

$7.67

made with organic strawberries from Stony Point Strawberry Farm

Strawberry Milk

$8.26

Creamy strawberry-flavored drink. Available in 12 oz or 16 oz. Choose from different milk types, including dairy and non-dairy. Optional house-made whipped cream topping.

Strawberry Horchata Milk

$8.26

organic strawberry & horchata syrups, cold milk & whipped cream

Horchata Steamer

$5.31

Steamed milk with our house-made syrup made with soaked rice and cinnamon sticks

Strawberry Horchata Steamer

$7.08

organic strawberry & horchata syrups with steamed milk

Apricot Oolong Iced Tea

$5.90

iced oolong tea (contains caffeine) balanced with sweet apricot syrup

Brown Butter Cafe au Lait

$5.90

Cafe au Lait with our house-made brown butter syrup

Matcha Latte

$6.20

unsweetened matcha latte with matcha from Blue Willow Tea

Kids Steamer

$4.13

Choice of hot drink sizes (8 oz, 12 oz, 16 oz). Milk options include whole, 1%, breve, oat, almond, soy, or coconut.

Tea Latte

$5.31

Various tea options like Earl Grey, Jasmine Green, and Mint Herbal; available in 8 oz, 12 oz, or 16 oz sizes. Choose from whole, oat, almond, and more milk options.

Hot Tea

$4.72

tea varieties from Blue Will Tea

Kids Glass of Milk

$4.13

Available in three sizes (8 oz, 12 oz, 16 oz). Choose from a variety of milk options including dairy, almond, oat, soy, and more.

Hot Chocolate

$5.90

Rich and creamy hot chocolate. Choose your size and milk type. Optional house-made whipped cream.

Chai Latte

$5.90

organic chai from Chico Chai

Iced Latte

$6.49

Chilled espresso with customizable milk options such as whole, 1%, breve, oat, almond, soy, or coconut milk. Available in 12 oz or 16 oz sizes.

Iced Matcha Latte

$6.78

12 oz, 16 oz. Milk options include dairy, oat, almond, soy, and coconut.

Iced Mocha

$7.96

Rich iced mocha, customizable sizes, variety of milk options, optional house-made whipped cream.

Iced Chai Latte

$6.49

Iced chai latte. Choose 12 oz or 16 oz. Milk options include dairy, oat, almond, soy, and more.

Iced White Chocolate Mocha

$7.96

made with our house-made Guittard white chocolate syrup *not available vegan* white chocolate contains dairy

Iced Americano

$4.72

Almond, coconut, oat, soy, 1%, whole, half & half. Additional room preferences available.

Arnold Palmer

$4.72

Iced tea and lemonade blend. Available in 12 oz or 16 oz sizes.

Matcha Tea Lemonade

$6.78

Refreshing blend of matcha green tea and lemonade. Choose between 12 oz and 16 oz sizes.

Lemonade

$4.72

Chilled lemonade available in 12 oz or 16 oz sizes.

Iced Tea

$4.72

unsweetened tea from Blue Willow Tea

Cold Brew

$5.90

Rich, smooth coffee served chilled. Choose 12 oz or 16 oz. Options for cream, various milk alternatives, or black.

Sparkling Americano

$5.31

Sparkling water infused with rich espresso. Available in 12 oz or 16 oz.

Guayaki Yerba Mate

$4.42

Guayaki yerba mate options: Sparkling Ginger, Lemon Elation, Revel Berry, Tropical Uprising, Enlighten Mint.

Mexican Coke, 500mL

$5.31

Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love

Diet Coke

$2.95

Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink

Health Ade Kombucha

$5.90

Fermented tea beverage. Options include fruity apple, zesty lemon, and tropical passionfruit.

La Croix

$2.36

Choice of Grapefruit, Lime, or Lemon flavored sparkling water.

Olipop

$4.42

Lotus root and truffle salad(sockfd, cilantro, yuzu vinaigrette, truffle oil).

San Pellegrino Italian Soda

$4.13

San Pellegrino Italian soda available in Pompelmo (grapefruit), Limonata (lemon), or Aranciata (orange) flavors.

San Pellegrino Sparkling Water

$4.72

Sparkling mineral water, sourced and bottled in Monterrey, Mexico, offering a refreshing and crisp taste.

Sprechers Soda

$4.13

Assorted Sprechers sodas. Choose from Root Beer, Cherry Cola, or Orange Cream.

Apple Juice

$5.31

Freshly pressed apple juice made from crisp, sweet apples. Refreshing and naturally sweet with a hint of tartness.

Bottled Water

$2.36

Quench your thirst with our pure and refreshing bottled water, offering crisp and clean hydration for any occasion.

Land and Water Coffee Beans

$23.60

Seasonal espresso, ACE series, and decaf seasonal espresso.

Everything Granola

$15.34

12 oz bag of our house-made granola

Raspberry Chia Seed Granola

$15.34

12 oz bag of our house-made granola

Sourdough Starter

$0.01

Naturally leavened mixture of flour and water, typically used to bake homemade sourdough bread.

Bagel Mill Tote Bag

$11.80

organic canvas tote

Blue Willow Loose Leaf Tea

$12.98

2 oz container of tea from Blue Willow Tea Company in Berkeley, CA.

Coffee Tumbler

$38.88

Reusable tumbler designed for coffee lovers. Typically features double-wall insulation to maintain beverage temperature and a secure lid to prevent spills.

Everything Mix

$10.62

a jar of our organic Everything Mix. Perfect for seasoning salads, veggies, eggs, meat and more!

NØRSE CØDE Plant Protein Powder

$52.51

local Petaluma product made with upcycled barley

Bagel Mill Trucker Hat

$37.75

trucker hat with logo

Bread Whole Wheat Flour 2lb.

$10.62

2 lb. bag of our house-milled flour

Coffee Mug

$14.16

White ceramic coffee mug with a simple design, perfect for enjoying your daily brew.

khorosan Flour 2lb.

$17.70

Einkorn flour 2lb: Einkorn flour, an ancient grain, typically used for baking bread, cookies, and pastries. Ideal for those seeking a unique, wholesome alternative to modern wheat.

Pastry Whole Wheat Flour 2lb.

$10.62

2 lb. bag of our house-milled flour

Rozeris Clay n Cloth

$14.16

Various canvas patches, plain or printed mugs, planter with plant.

Rye Whole Wheat Flour 2lb.

$10.62

2 lb. bag of our house-milled flour

Bagel Mill Beanie

$30.67

charcoal beanie with logo on front

Bagel Mill Hoodie

$64.89

Bella + Canvas charcoal hoodie with logo on front and back