1886 Prime

Gluten Free Pizza

$13.00

Gluten-free pizza crust with classic cheese and sauce.

Garlic Pan

$24.55

Golden-brown crust topped with melted cheese and a hint of garlic.

Garlic NY- Small

$15.60

Garlic NY (Small): Garlic butter base, no red sauce, topped with cheese and Italian herbs, cut into foldable slices.

Garlic NY - Large

$24.55

A large New York-style pizza featuring a garlic butter base, cheese, and Italian herbs, cut into foldable slices.

House Pizza

$24.55

A rectangular pizza topped with rich tomato sauce and a sprinkle of grated cheese.

Old Fashioned Pan Pizza

$24.55

Generously topped with pepperoni on a thick, crispy crust with melted cheese and rich tomato sauce.

Large NY Style Pizza

$24.55

Generously topped with pepperoni slices and melted mozzarella on a classic New York-style thin crust.

Small Pizza

$15.60

Classic New York-style thin crust pizza, typically includes tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Purple Cow Wings - Regular

$16.85+

Chicken wings available in quantities of 10, 20, 30, 40, or 50.

Purple Cow Wings - Boneless

$15.55+

Chicken wings with choice of size: 10, 20, 30, 40, or 50 pieces.

Buffalo Wings - Boneless

$15.55+

Boneless buffalo wings with various sauce options. Size options: 10 to 50 wings. Sauces include BBQ, garlic parmesan, spicy ranch, and more.

Buffalo Wings - Regular

$16.85+

Buffalo wings. Choose from various sizes: 10 to 50 pieces. Multiple sauce options including BBQ, Garlic Parm, Hot, Lemon Pepper, Medium, Mild, Plain, and more.

(10) Boneless

$20.25

Boneless chicken wings: choose from a variety of sauces including BBQ, Garlic Parm, Hot, Lemon Pepper, and more.

True EBA

$33.80

Pan with Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Peppers, Red Onions

Margherita

$26.30

NY with Fresh Basil & Mozzarella

Pizza Isabella

$28.90

Baked on house shell with sauce over cheese, topped with fresh sausage, banana peppers, fresh mozzarella pearls, hot pepper flakes & Pecorino Romano.

Purple Cow Pizza

$31.55

NY with Our Legendary Purple Cow Sauce Topped with Purple Cow Chicken with Our Legendary Purple Cow Sauce Topped with Purple Cow Chicken

White Pizza

$28.60

Pan or NY with Garlic & Ricotta

Bleecker St

$28.90

House with Sausage

5 Star Pizza

$31.20

NY with Cherry Tomatoes, Ricotta & Basil

Big T

$33.50

Pan with Pepperoni, Red Onion, Purple Cow Chicken, Scallions & Bacon

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$28.90

NY with Medium Buffalo Chicken

Vampire Slayer

$28.90

Garlic Pan with Pepperoni, Cherry Peppers & Red Onion

CBR Pizza

$31.20

NY with Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Ranch

Big Daddy Pizza

$34.15

Old Fashioned Pan Style with Pepperoni, Sausage, Meatballs, Peppers & Mushrooms

Thinnie Minnie

$28.90

NY Extra Thin with Roasted Garlic Base, Pepperoni, Buffalo Chicken and House Pizza Sauce Drizzle & Pecorino Romano

ATW PC Pizza

$31.55

NY with Purple Cow Chicken, Everything Sauce Ranch Drizzle, Bacon Bits & Scallions

King of Orchard

$25.55

Garlic Pan with Sausage & Hot Peppers

Vega Roni

$28.90

NY with Pepperoni & Buffalo Chicken

Hot Mama Pizza

$31.55

NY with Longhots, Ricotta, Cherry Peppers, Sausage & Utica Grind Pepper Flakes

BGR Pizza

$31.20

Pan or NY with Garlic, Ricotta & Broccoli

Main Street

$31.55

Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers.

Prince Street

$28.90

Grandma Style with Spicy Vodka Sauce, Pepperoni, Seasoned Ricotta & TR’s Hot Honey Drizzle

BBQ Chicken Pizza

$31.55

NY style with Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Scallions, Cheddar Cheese & Dad’s Homemade BBQ Sauce

Large & 15

$45.95

Large pizza with choice of AS House, Old Fashioned, NY, or Garlic Pan styles. Wings: Boneless or regular. Sauces include BBQ, Black & Blue, Garlic Parm, plus various spicy and mild options.

Large & 40

$72.25

Large 40-inch Pizza: Choice of AS House, Old Fashioned, NY, or Garlic Pan. Wings available boneless or regular, with sauces ranging from BBQ to Reaper.

Small & 15

$32.65

Small pizza paired with 15 wings. Wing choice: Boneless or Regular. Sauce options: BBQ, Black & Blue, Garlic Parm, Mild, and more.

Antipasto

$27.30

Romaine Lettuce, House Roast Beef, Salami, Ham, Provolone, Fresh Mozzarella, Grape Tomatoes & Croutons

Fried Mozz

$15.60

Crispy breaded mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce and garnished with grated cheese and fresh herbs.

Fresh Cut Fries

$6.50

Crispy, golden fries made from freshly cut potatoes, lightly seasoned with herbs.

Chicken Tenders

$14.45

Battered and fried chicken tenders, typically served with a dipping sauce.

Arancini

$14.45

Deep-fried risotto balls filled with arborio rice and fontina cheese, complemented by marinara sauce.

Greens

$18.20

Caesar Salad

$9.10

Classic Caesar Salad with Crisp Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons, and Signature Caesar Dressing.

Cheesy Garlic Bread

$7.25

Toasted baguette slices topped with melted cheese and a blend of garlic and herbs.

Roasted Longhots

$15.60

Roasted long hot peppers, typically served with a light drizzle of olive oil and a sprinkle of sea salt.

Garden Salad

$7.80

Fresh mixed greens with seasonal vegetables

Garlic Knots

$7.25

Garlic-infused knots of warm, freshly baked bread with a flavorful twist.

Onion Rings

$11.70

Crispy golden-fried onion rings, perfectly seasoned for a savory crunch.

Tuscan Chicken Salad

$19.50

Grilled Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Grape Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Fresh Mozzarella, Prosciutto and Croutons

Chicken Caesar Salad

$18.20

Crisp romaine, tender grilled chicken, shaved Parmesan, and croutons, all drizzled with classic Caesar dressing.

Steak Salad

$27.30

Sliced Filet, Romaine Lettuce, Caramelized Onions, Roasted Red Peppers, Grape Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Fresh Mozzarella and Croutons

Black & Bleu Burger

$15.75+

With House-made Bleu Cheese & Shredded Romaine

Single Cheeseburger (No Fries)

$9.10

Single beef patty, typically includes cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and onions on a toasted bun with house sauce.

Double Burger (No Fries)

$13.00

Two beef patties, lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, mayo, and ketchup on a bun.

Triple Burger (No Fries)

$16.90

Three beef patties, lettuce, tomato, mayo, ketchup, on a toasted bun.

ATW Burger

$15.75+

Cheddar, Bacon, Shredded Lettuce, Scallions & Everything Sauce

Chophouse Burger

$15.75+

Diced Onions, Ketchup & Mustard

Bacon & Swiss Burger

$15.75+

Bacon with Swiss

CBR Burger

$15.75+

Bacon, Ranch Dressing & Melted Cheddar Cheese

PC Burger

$15.75+

Bleu Cheese, Caramelized Onions, Shredded Lettuce & Signature Purple Cow Sauce

Large Sub

$18.20

Black & White Hero

$20.80

Thin Sliced Ham, Salami, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato w/ Black & White Sauce

Chicken Parm Tunnel

$22.75

With Mozzarella & Marinara

Small Sub

$10.40

Chicken Cali Tunnel

$23.40

With Spring Mix, Mozzarella, Bacon, Tomato & Cali Sauce

Chicken Vodka Parm Tunnel

$22.75

With Mozzarella & Vodka Sauce

Roast Beef Hero

$22.10

House Roasted Beef, Salami, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Swiss Cheese, with Black & White Hero Dressing

Tenderloin Tunnel w/ Cheese

$32.50+

Tenderloin served in three sizes: small, medium, large. Choose your desired meat temperature: rare, medium rare, medium, medium well, or well done.

Chicken Cutlet Tunnel

$19.70

With Spring Mix, Provolone & Balsamic Reduction

Parm Encrusted Chicken

$31.20

Rigatoni pasta topped with crispy Parmesan-crusted chicken, drizzled with a creamy sauce and garnished with herbs.

Chicken Riggies

$29.90

Tender pasta with chicken, customizable spice level—mild, medium, or hot.

Pasta Side

$5.20

Ravioli and Meatballs

$20.80

Ravioli filled with ricotta cheese, paired with meatballs sautéed with garlic, bell peppers, and onions, all in our house-made marinara sauce.

Side Meatball (1)

$1.95

House-made meatball typically accompanied by marinara sauce and parmesan cheese.

6oz Sauce

$3.90

bread pudding

$6.50

Dad's Cheesecake Slice

$7.80

Creamy cheesecake topped with a rich raspberry sauce, garnished with fresh raspberries and dollops of whipped cream.

Whole Cheesecake

$71.50

Dense and creamy whole cheesecake with a classic graham cracker crust, typically complemented by fruit or chocolate toppings.

2oz Sauce Cup

$1.00

A 2oz sauce cup typically includes a blend of various ingredients such as mayo, mustard, or spices, designed to complement your meal.

2oz Salad Dressing

$1.30

Salad dressing (2oz): Typically includes a blend of oils, vinegar, herbs, and spices, crafted to complement fresh salads.

Celery & Blue Cheese

$4.55

Crisp celery paired with house-made blue cheese dressing.

4oz Bleu Cheese

$2.60

House-made bleu cheese dressing with a creamy, chunky texture and balanced flavor.

Bottle

$3.60

Assorted bottled beverages typically include options like water, coke, diet coke, sprite, or dr. pepper.

Glass Bottles/Pellegrino

$3.90

Sparkling natural mineral water in glass bottles, typically known for its crisp taste and fine bubbles, offering a refreshing and sophisticated drinking experience.