Butteriffic Bakery & Cafe

Classic Banana Pudding

$8.00

Classic Banana Pudding made with Butter Cookies

Build a Butteriffic Box

$29.00

Build your "Butteriffic dozen" today! Choose up to 14 of our most popular cookie flavors! All 14 cookies are baked fresh and individually wrapped to ensure a Butteriffic experience... You butter believe it!

Butteriffic Dozen

$29.00

Butteriffic butter bliss box - savor the exquisite simplicity of our Butteriffic dozen of butter cookies at Butteriffic. Each cookie is a testament to the artistry of buttery perfection, delicately baked to golden-brown bliss. Immerse yourself in the rich, melt-in-your-mouth experience as the subtle sweetness of premium butter takes center stage. Whether you're indulging in the delicate crumble or reveling in the sheer elegance of these treats, our butter cookies are a timeless classic. Elevate your taste with a Butteriffic dozen of these golden delights, a perfect complement to any occasion or a moment of pure, Butteriffic pleasure. 14 Butteriffic butter cookies.

Large Butteriffic Cookie Jar

$30.00

Gold Bags (6 Pieces)

$50.00

6oz gold bags full of mini Butteriffic butter cookies. Each bag is a treasure trove of golden-brown delights, boasting a perfect balance of buttery goodness and irresistible crunch. Savor the iconic taste of Memphis in every bite, a symphony of flavors that captures the essence of southern hospitality. Treat yourself to the warmth and sweetness that only our gold bag of cookies can deliver. You can also mix Butteriffic golden bags with six, twelve, and twenty-four gold bags containing butter, butter pecan, strawberry butter, coconut Butter, and lemon butter.

Gold Bags (12 Pieces)

$95.00

6oz gold bags full of mini Butteriffic butter cookies. Each bag is a treasure trove of golden-brown delights, boasting a perfect balance of buttery goodness and irresistible crunch. Savor the iconic taste of Memphis in every bite, a symphony of flavors that captures the essence of southern hospitality. Treat yourself to the warmth and sweetness that only our gold bag of cookies can deliver. You can also mix Butteriffic golden bags with six, twelve, and twenty-four gold bags containing butter, butter pecan, strawberry butter, coconut Butter, and lemon butter.

Gold Bags (24 Pieces)

$180.00

6oz gold bags full of mini Butteriffic butter cookies. Each bag is a treasure trove of golden-brown delights, boasting a perfect balance of buttery goodness and irresistible crunch. Savor the iconic taste of Memphis in every bite, a symphony of flavors that captures the essence of southern hospitality. Treat yourself to the warmth and sweetness that only our gold bag of cookies can deliver. You can also mix Butteriffic golden bags with six, twelve, and twenty-four gold bags containing butter, butter pecan, strawberry butter, coconut Butter, and lemon butter.

Medium Butteriffic Cookie Jar

$20.00

A jar of your favorite mini butter cookies! Classic Butter Cookies Only

Gold Bags (1 Piece)

$9.01

6oz gold bags full of mini Butteriffic butter cookies. Each bag is a treasure trove of golden-brown delights, boasting a perfect balance of buttery goodness and irresistible crunch. Savor the iconic taste of Memphis in every bite, a symphony of flavors that captures the essence of southern hospitality. Treat yourself to the warmth and sweetness that only our gold bag of cookies can deliver. You can also mix Butteriffic golden bags with six, twelve, and twenty-four gold bags containing butter or butter pecan

Butteriffic Pies (9 In) 24 hour notice on all pies

$32.00

Pecan pie with butter cookie crust from Butteriffic Bakery & Cafe! This luxurious dessert takes pecan pie to the next level with a melt-in-your-mouth butter cookie crust, offering a sweet, crumbly base that perfectly complements the rich pecan filling. Topped with toasted, locally sourced pecans and a smooth caramel-like filling, this pie is both indulgent and unique. The butter cookie crust adds a delightful twist, giving each bite a subtle, buttery flavor that elevates the traditional southern favorite. Ideal for holidays or special gatherings, this pie serves up to 10 slices of pure comfort and joy!

Personal Butteriffic Pecan Pies - 4-Pack

$40.00

Four 5-inch homemade pecan pie with butter cookie crust from Butteriffic Bakery & Cafe! This luxurious dessert takes pecan pie to the next level with a melt-in-your-mouth butter cookie crust, offering a sweet, crumbly base that perfectly complements the rich pecan filling. Topped with toasted, locally sourced pecans and a smooth caramel-like filling, this pie is both indulgent and unique. The butter cookie crust adds a delightful twist, giving each bite a subtle, buttery flavor that elevates the traditional southern favorite.