Full menu
The BP Reuben (Heated)
$12.95
Our cured and slow roasted corned beef is a lean-side, flavorful cut that we slice thin to win and gluten-free! Served with fresh sauerkraut and your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Turkey Breast
$11.95
Our thinly sliced turkey breast is a popular favorite and comes with your choice of fresh toppings piled high soft, fresh baked 9" frame bread.
The BP Cuban (Heated)
Heated and toasted "Cuban-style" sandwich with thinly sliced ham, roast pork, Swiss, pickles and choice of fresh toppings on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread.. We recommend mayo and spicy mustard!
Turkey Club with Bacon
$14.50
Thinly sliced turkey breast and crisp bacon with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Roast Beef
Our roast beef is lean-side, flavorful cut, slow roasted, sliced thin, and gluten-free. Served with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
BLT
Heated and toasted sandwich with crisp bacon and your choice of fresh toppings (like lettuce and tomato) piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread. . We recommend mayo!
Chicken Salad
Our popular homemade chicken salad is made with oven-roasted chicken breast, celery, mayo and seasonings. Served with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread.
Tuna Salad
$10.95
Homemade tuna salad with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Egg & Olive
Homemade egg & green olive salad with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Corned Beef
Our cured and slow roasted corned beef is a lean-side, flavorful cut that we slice thin to win and gluten-free! Served with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Ham & Cheese
Thinly sliced ham with your choice of cheese and fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Ham-Bone (Ham, Turkey & Swiss)
Thinly sliced turkey, ham & swiss with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread.
Bologna
$9.95
When is the last time you had a bologna sandwich? Thinly sliced beef bologna with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread will take you back to childhood memories.
Italian w/Italian Tomatoes
Thinly sliced capocollo, salami, pepperoni, provolone & Italian tomato with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread. We recommend adding sub oil with mayo!
Veggie
Roasted red peppers & sliced cucumbers with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Capocollo
Thinly sliced capocollo with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Liverwurst
When is the last time you had a liverwurst sandwich? Freshly sliced to order with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread will take you back to childhood memories.
PB & J
$6.00
Feel like your younger self with a good ol' fashioned Peanut Butter and Jelly sandwich! Creamy peanut butter & strawberry jam on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Roast Pork
Thinly sliced roast pork with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Hard Salami
Thinly sliced hard salami with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Cheese
Thinly sliced cheese with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Brooklyn Pickle Special
Popular Brooklyn Pickle favorite! This sandwich comes with corned beef, pastrami, homemade Russian dressing and Swiss Cheese on dark rye bread. Add fresh shredded lettuce, sliced tomatoes and onions for no additional charge!
Pastrami
Choice of bread and toppingsOur hand-trimmed pastrami is a rich and smoky lean-side New York cut, thin sliced, gluten free and served with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 9” frame bread
Turkey Breast Sub
Our thinly sliced turkey breast is a popular favorite and comes with your choice of fresh toppings piled high soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll. Try it with our homemade Chipotle Ranch dressing!
Italian Sub w/Italian Tomatoes
Thinly sliced capocollo, salami, pepperoni, provolone & Italian tomato with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll. We recommend adding sub oil with mayo!
Meatball on 8" Roll
Our meatball sub comes with three large meatballs, served with provolone cheese on a soft 8" roll. Add some grated parmesan and oregano. If you like your roll "toasted", don't forget to note it and we'll make it happen!
Ham & Cheese Sub
Thinly sliced ham with your choice of cheese and fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Roast Beef Sub
Our roast beef is lean-side, flavorful cut, slow roasted, sliced thin, and gluten-free. Served with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Chicken Salad Sub
Our popular homemade chicken salad is made with oven-roasted chicken breast, celery, mayo and seasonings. Served with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12” sub roll
BLT Sub
Heated and toasted sub with crisp bacon and your choice of fresh toppings (like lettuce and tomato) piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll. We recommend mayo!
Corned Beef Sub
Our cured and slow roasted corned beef is a lean-side, flavorful cut that we slice thin to win and gluten-free! Served with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Hard Salami Sub
Thinly sliced hard salami with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Tuna Salad Sub
Homemade tuna salad with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Bologna Sub
$8.95
When is the last time you had a bologna sandwich? Thinly sliced beef bologna with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll will take you back to childhood memories.
Egg & Olive Sub
Homemade egg & green olive salad with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Ham-Bone Sub (Ham, Turkey & Swiss)
Thinly sliced turkey, ham & swiss with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12” sub roll
Capocollo Sub
Thinly sliced capocollo with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Veggie Sub
Roasted red peppers & sliced cucumbers with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Cheese Sub
Thinly sliced cheese with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Roast Pork Sub
Thinly sliced roast pork with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Liverwurst Sub
When is the last time you had a liverwurst sandwich? Freshly sliced to order with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll will take you back to childhood memories.
Brooklyn Pickle Special Sub
Thinly sliced gluten free corned beef, pastrami, & Swiss with choice of fresh toppings on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll. We recommend heavy Russian dressing!
Pastrami Sub
Our hand-trimmed pastrami is a rich and smoky lean-side New York cut, thin sliced, gluten free and served with your choice of fresh toppings piled high on soft, fresh baked 12" sub roll
Wraps
Choose your favorite sandwich/sub as a wrap!!
Matzo Ball Soup (Bowl) - Raleigh only
This comforting, traditional soup with vegetables in our famous chicken soup bone broth and handmade matzo ball dumplings (thanks to pro tips from our neighbors Betty and Greta)!
Homemade Chili
$5.95
Our hearty classic beef chili with kidney beans, tomatos, onions and spices
Homemade Chicken Noodle
Our famous chicken noodle soup is made with nutritious homemade bone broth and fresh vegetables
Hot Daily Chef's Special
$6.45
Daily Chef's Specials are posted daily on Facebook & Instagram @BrooklynPickleNC: - Chicken Riggies (pictured, every Thurs) - Mac & Cheese (every Fri)
Brooklyn Cobb Salad
$13.95
Romaine, roasted chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg, crumbled blue cheese, grape tomatoes, cucumbers & carrots
Garden Salad
Romaine, cucumbers, carrots, grape tomatoes, green & red peppers & croutons (optional). Add protein with a scoop of homemade Chicken, Tuna or Egg & Olive Salad!
Homemade Potato Salad
$3.75
Red potatoes, hardboiled eggs, onion, mayo, mustard & seasonings
Potato Knish
$4.50
Since 1921, Gabila’s has been “Brooklyn’s Original Coney Island Square Knish”, which are lightly seasoned mashed potato pies that are popular as a snack, appetizer or side. We recommend enjoying them with a good spicy deli-style mustard!
Homemade Macaroni Salad
Macaroni noodles, carrots, onions, mayo, mustard & seasonings
Add a scoop (Chicken, Tuna or Egg Salad)
$5.25
Scoop of egg, tuna or chicken salad.
Homemade Coleslaw
Our tangy slaw with cabbage, carrots, mayo & seasonings. Perfect with one of our corned beef or pastrami sandwiches!
Homemade Pasta Salad
Rotini noodles, onions, vegetables and parmesan cheese tossed in balsamic vinaigrette and seasonings
Homemade Broccoli Salad
Our popular new "slaw-style" salad with broccoli, onion, raisin, mayo & seasonings
Brooklyn Club Salad
Freshly cut romaine lettuce, turkey, ham, Swiss cheese, croutons, cucumber, carrots & grape tomatoes. Suggested dressing: housemade Balsamic Vinaigrette or Buttermilk Ranch
Chicken Caesar
Juicy oven-roasted chicken breast with shaved parmesan and croutons (optional) over romaine lettuce. Try it with our delicious, homemade Creamy Caesar dressing!
Quart Dill Pickles
A whole quart of our tangy and delicious pickles, cut into spears to share!
Quart Full Sour Pickles
Whole Dill Pickle
$3.50
A dill pickle is always tangy and delicious!
Brooklyn Full Sour Pickle
Homemade Banana Pudding
Our popular homemade dessert has layers of custard pudding, vanilla wafers and sliced fresh bananas, topped with whipped cream
Dirty Chips (small, 2.0 oz)
Artfully Crafted, Partially Peeled, Thick Cut Kettle Style For The Perfect Crunch!
NY Style Cheesecake with Cherries
$6.95
Cherry topping with a slice of our large, 10-inch New York-style cheesecake with a rich, firm, melt-in-your-mouth delicious cream cheese filling and shortbread cookie crumb crust
Homemade Cream Cheese Brownie
$4.25
Our unique, moist & delicious cream cheese brownies are steam baked with a layer of cheesecake
Jumbo Cookies
$3.35
Our popular and delicious, fresh-baked cookies are 4.5 oz each and made with no added preservatives. Choose from chocolate chip and our new oatmeal & raisin!
Black and White Cookie
$4.45
Soft, cakey cookies with a subtle lemon flavor, frosted with half chocolate and half vanilla icing, making them a New York City classic
NY Style Cheesecake
Slice of our large, 10-inch New York-style cheesecake with a rich, firm, melt-in-your-mouth delicious cream cheese filling and shortbread cookie crumb crust
Homemade Brownie with Walnuts
$3.45
Try our homemade walnut brownies, made and baked on site everyday!
Chocolate Pudding
$5.45
Our classic chocolate pudding is topped with chocolate chips and whipped cream
Rice Pudding
Our creamy rice pudding is topped with cinnamon and whipped cream
Dr. Brown
$3.25
A true New York original since 1869, Dr. Brown's amazing, authentic flavors epitomize what great sodas should taste like – and they pair perfectly with our BP Special!
Pure Leaf Teas (20 oz)
Brewed using freshly picked tea leaves so every sip is as sweet as the last.
12 oz Can (Soda)
$2.50
Chocolate Milk
$3.95
14 oz bottle of Fairlife's 2% reduced fat chocolate milk!
20 oz Bottle (Soda)
20 oz Bottle (Water)
Aquafina 20 oz bottle
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: