Full menu
Half Dozen
$13.80
We know, we know – how can you ever commit to one or two of our cookies with all of those delicious options? Let us put six together for you so you can get all the goodness!
Baker's Dozen
$29.00
The perfect menu option to try all of our famous flavors and have some leftover to share. Treat yourself, treat the office, bring some home to your roommates, or show the family some love.
Ice Cream Sandwich
$10.00
Try the made-to-order treat that made us famous! Pick any two of our made-from-scratch cookies and a flavor of delicious local ice cream and we’ll combine them into the most amazing ice cream sandwich!
Milkshake
$9.20
Combine the best ice cream and milk from local creameries for a delightful treat! We offer chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry, as well as the occasional special if you stop by to see us.
Edible Cookie Dough
$5.70
We heat treat our flour and use pasteurized egg in this special dough made just for eating – straight from the jar! Pick your favorite of our 5 flavors!
Chocolate Ice Cream (Local)
$5.75
We source all of our ice cream from Homeland Creamery, in Julian, NC! This sustainable farm’s chocolate ice cream is “utterly” delicious!
The Duo (Cookie + Scoop)
$7.50
Cookies & Milk Combo
$9.60
Make it a combo and save. Pick any two of our made-from-scratch cookies and a flavor of delicious local milk!
Soda Float
$6.50
Combine your favorite bubbly beverages with our local creamery products for the perfect pairing!
Strawberry Ice Cream (Local)
Homeland Creamery’s delicious fruity ice cream promises to be some of the best you’ve ever had!
Local Milk
$4.80
Our selection of 12 oz milks come from local NC dairy Homeland Creamery, in Guilford County. Fresh from the farm to you, for the perfect companion to our made-from-scratch cookies!
Snickerdoodle Cookie
$3.00
Our made-from-scratch snickerdoodles will send you right back to grandma’s kitchen. Take a deep breath, that’s the delicious scent of cinnamon!
Peanut Butter Cookie
Just enough crisp, just enough crumble, and all that smoothness of the best peanut butter. Pair it with a cold glass of milk from our local dairy farm and experience the perfect pair.
Vanilla Ice Cream (Local)
Sourced from a 7th generation family farm in Guilford County, NC, this vanilla ice cream has an extra creamy taste!
Chocolate Chip Cookie
This cookie is what it’s all about – literally the reason for the existence of captain cookie. Try it and you’ll instantly understand why!
Confetti Cookie
Put some fun in your day with our most playful cookie!
Double Chocolate Cookie
Chocolate lovers – prepare yourselves. Our made-from-scratch double chocolate cookies are rich, delectable, and will melt in your mouth!
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
For many, oatmeal raisin is the only cookie that exists. Try out our classic recipe – a chewy cookie with just the right amount of crispness, spice, and, of course, raisins!
Ginger Molasses Cookie
The hidden gem of our cookie lineup. One bite and you’ll be a fan for life!
Vegan Chocolate Chip
We knew we’d mastered our vegan chocolate chip recipe when Kirk tricked juliann into thinking it was a regular chocolate chip cookie. We are so dedicated to having our vegan recipe be on pars with our others that we churn our own vegan “butter” from scratch – come taste the difference!
Soda
$2.40
We keep all the classic bubbly beverages in stock for you! We offer Coke, Diet Coke & Sprite.
Bake at Home Dough Kits (One Dozen)
$14.00
We offer our bake at home dough kits in the flavors: Chocolate Chip, Confetti, and Double Chocolate. Due to our packaging, we cannot mix and match an individual dozen—unfortunately, we are unable to mix 6 cookies of one and 6 of another in the same package. However, these cookies are so delicious you’ll want 6 more anyway! Customers can order multiple dozens mixed (ex. Order 2 dozen: 1 Chocolate Chip, 1 Confetti).
Bake at Home Dough Kits (Two Dozen)
$26.00
Gift Box
$32.20
Cookies for a Crowd
$57.50
Please let us know if you have any specific flavor preferences! We offer chocolate chip cookie, snickerdoodle cookie, confetti cookie, double chocolate cookie, oatmeal raisin cookie, ginger molasses cookie, peanut butter cookie, and vegan chocolate chip.
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: