Full menu
MEDIUM CUP
$8.22
UP to 3 scoops Medium Cup
LARGE / PINT
$10.42
3 Large Scoops Pint Cup
Coney Waffle
$8.77
3 Scoops of your choice Ice Cream - Get three scoops the same or mix three flavors.
MILKSHAKE
$4.93
Hand-spun milkshakes crafted with creamy ice cream, topped with a generous swirl of whipped cream, available in over 50 delightful flavors. Kids 12oz ,Small 20oz, Large 32oz
QUART
$14.26
4 Large Scoops Quart Cup
Ice Cream Sandwiches
$16.46
6-Pack of Ice Cream Sandwiches with a choice of Vanilla Chocolate Chip or Vanilla Oreo ice cream sandwiches!
Sprinkle Dipped Bowl/Cone
$9.87
The American Firecracker
$9.05
Celebrate the chill of freedom with The American Firecracker—our explosive blend of Italian ice, layered with creamy soft serve and sprinkled with rainbow sprinkles. It’s the taste of summer, served up Coney-style. Available in 20oz or 32oz(Red White & Boom Pictured)
Italian Ice
$4.38
Coney Chillato
A refreshing combination of Italian ice and creamy soft serve ice cream, blended to a smooth and delightful consistency. Get Ready for the Flavor Explosion of the season!! Whipped cream & Rainbow Sprinkles
Plain Waffle Waffle Cone/Bowl
$9.32
Plain Waffle Cone or Bowl
BROWNIE WAFFLE
$9.60
A soft and chewy brownie pressed into a waffle shape, offering a rich and fudgy texture filled with 3 generous scoops of creamy, homemade ice cream
1/2 Gallon
$25.78
A generous 1/2 Gallon serving of rich and creamy Ice Cream, available in a choice of over 60 luscious flavors, perfect for sharing with the family.
Brookie Ice Cream Sandwiches
$24.13
4-Pack of our BROOKIE Ice Cream Sandwiches - vanilla or chocolate ice cream sandwiched between a fudgey brownie and a chocolate chip cookie!
Oreo Treat Ice Cream Sandwich
Oreo ice cream wrapped in Oreo Cookie Marshmallow treats. One Bite is all it's going to take!
Ice Cream Filled Cannoli (Two)
$10.08
Two Cannoli Filled with Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream
Float (Soda)
Choose from over 75 ice cream flavors and pair it with any of our crispy, flavored effervescent drinks, including the full Stewart's lineup. Floats for pickup and delivery are packaged UN-assembled without whipped cream.
Shirley Temple Ice Cream Float
$10.70
A delightful combination of creamy vanilla ice cream and a splash of grenadine syrup, topped with fizzy lemon-lime soda and garnished with sweet maraschino cherries & Whipped Cream. *Items ordered for delivery will arrive Un poured and DO NOT include Whipped Cream
Cereal Sundae
Cereal Sunday. Choose up to 2 flavors of ice cream.
Italian Ice Shake
Refreshing Italian ice blended seamlessly with your choice of creamy milk, tangy lemonade, or chilled ice tea to create a smooth and invigorating shake.
Pup Cup
$1.64
Cherries Underground
$10.97
A hearty serving of Sweet maraschino cherries buried beneath a creamy swirl of the soft serve of your choice, creating a hidden delight in every scoop. Sold in 12 oz serving Choose up to two flavors! (Single Selection will result in both servings in single choice)
Beach Ball Sandwich
$7.13
1 Large Scoop Ice Cream
Ice Cream Sandwich Singles
$3.83
Creamy vanilla ice cream sandwiched between two cookies and adorned with colorful sprinkles, chocolate chips or plain, creating a delightful treat.
Rainbow Bowl/Cone
12 Flavor Ice Cream Sampler
$34.84
A delightful assortment of 12 hand crafted creamy ice cream flavors, approximately 4 oz each, offering a diverse range of tastes from rich chocolate to tangy fruit.
SMALL CUP
$6.85
2 Scoops of Ice Cream
KIDS CUP
1 Scoop of Ice Cream
Toppings
Reese's Peanut Butter Waffle Sundae
$12.62
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate & Peanut Butter Drizzle, Crushed Reese's and Reese's Pieces.
Ferrero Rocher Nutella Waffle Sundae
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Nutella Drizzle, Cake Crunch, Ferrero Rocher & Chocolate Chips
Reese's Brownie Sundae
$14.61
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Reese's Pieces, Crushed Reese's, Peanut Butter Sauce & Chocolate Drizzle
Cookie Butter Biscoff Waffle Sundae
A Coney Waffle with Cookie Butter Ice Cream, Biscoff & Butterscotch Drizzle, Ground Biscoff & topped with a Biscoff cookie!
Cookie Dough Brownie Sundae
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Cookie Dough pieces.
Reese's Peanut Butter Milkshake
Reese's Peanut Butter Milkshake with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Crushed Reese's, Reese's Pieces, Chocolate Drizzle & Peanut Butter Drizzle
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Reese's Peanut Butter Sundae
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Reese's Pieces, Crushed Reese's, Chocolate Drizzle & Peanut Butter Drizzle
S'mores Brownie Sundae
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with crushed graham crackers, chocolate chips, mini marshmallows, and s Chocolate and Marshmallow Drizzle.
S'mores Waffle Sundae
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate & Marshmallow Drizzle, Chocolate Chips, crushed Graham crackers, and mini Marshmallows
Cookie Dough Waffle Sundae
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Drizzle, Cookie Dough pieces & chocolate chips.
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Dough Sundae
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Cookie Dough pieces.
M&M Waffle Sundae
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Drizzle and mini M&M's
Double Chocolate Brownie Sundae
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Chocolate Chips, Chocolate Drizzle, and Chocolate Cake Crunch
Nutella Ferrero Rocher Milkshake
A Vanilla or Chocolate Nutella Milkshake topped with Whipped Cream, Nutella Drizzle, Chocolate Chips, Cake Crunch, and a Ferrero Rocher
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Ferrero Rocher Nutella Sundae
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, chocolate cake crunch, Nutella drizzle & a Ferrero Rocher
S'mores Milkshake
A S'mores Milkshake with Brownie S'mores ice cream, topped with Whipped Cream, Marshmallow, Chocolate Drizzle, mini marshmallows, chocolate chips & graham cracker pieces
Oreo Milkshake
An Oreo Milkshake with Oreo ice cream, topped with Whipped Cream, Chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Oreo pieces.
Oreo Brownie Sundae
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, crushed Oreos & Chocolate Drizzle.
Oreo Waffle Sundae
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Drizzle, Chocolate Chips, and Crushed Oreos
Giant 1/2lb Cookie S'mores Sundae
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with crushed Graham crackers, chocolate chips, mini marshmallows, and a Marshmallow & Chocolate Drizzle
Mangonada
20oz Popular Mexican frozen beverage made from ripe mangoes, lime juice, chamoy sauce, and chili-lime salt. It combines sweet, tangy, spicy, and savory flavors for an exotic, refreshing taste, perfect for serving any day of the year! Served with a Tamarind Candy Straw.
Cookie Dough Milkshake
A Cookie Dough Milkshake with Cookie Dough ice cream, topped with Whipped Cream, Chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Cookie Dough pieces.
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Chocolate Sundae
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, chocolate cake crunch, and a chocolate drizzle
M&M Brownie Sundae
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with M&M's & Chocolate Drizzle
M&M's Milkshake
M&M Milkshake with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with Whipped Cream, mini M&M's & a Chocolate Drizzle.
Double Chocolate Waffle Sundae
Coney Waffle & Ice Cream with Chocolate Drizzle & Chocolate Chips, and Chocolate Cake Crunch
Giant 1/2lb Cookie Oreo Sundae
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle & Oreo pieces.
Double Chocolate Milkshake
A Chocolate Milkshake with Chocolate Ice Cream, topped with Chocolate chips, Chocolate Drizzle, Whipped Cream & Cherry
Giant 1/2lb Cookie M&M Sundae
A Giant 1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip Cookie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with mini M&M's & Chocolate Drizzle
Pistachio Oreo Waffle Sundae
A freshly cooked coney waffle filled with creamy pistachio soft serve, crushed Oreos, drizzled chocolate sauce, and sprinkled with chocolate chips.
Ferrero Rocher Nutella Brownie Sundae
A decadent chocolate brownie with Vanilla or Chocolate ice cream, topped with chocolate cake crunch, mini chocolate chips, Nutella drizzle, and a Ferrero Rocher
Carrot Cake
A Hearty serving of moist carrot cake infused with a warm blend of spices, walnuts, coconut flakes and sweet raisins, topped with a rich cream cheese frosting.
Brownies
$5.75
Assorted brownie flavors
Cherry Cheesecake
$7.40
A rich and creamy cheesecake made with smooth cream cheese, topped with sweet tangy cherries, and set on a buttery graham cracker crust. The texture is light and fluffy, making each bite a delightful treat. Comes with Cherry Topping unless specified otherwise.
Giant Cookie
A freshly baked giant cookie available in assorted flavors, offering a delightful variety of tastes to savor.
Italian Cannoli (One)
Fresh Filled Cannoli
Chocolate chip Cream Pie 3 Pack
$11.52
Enjoy the perfect blend of soft chocolate chip cookies and rich buttercream filling with this 3-pack of CreamPie sandwiches. Each bite offers a creamy texture and delicious flavor, ideal for any sweet craving. Served with 2 rainbow and 1 chocolate sprinkle cups.
Banana Pudding
Layers of bananas, vanilla wafers, creamy homemade pudding, and whipped cream.
Rice Pudding
Creamy rice pudding, topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon
Cotton Candy Large
Coney Cotton Candy
Cereal Treat
$5.48
Taffy Pail
Delightfully chewy salt water taffy, sweetened to perfection, presented in convenient fun pail with approximately 35 pieces each.
Cotton Candy Small
$6.03
Ring Pop
$1.36
A strawberry-flavored candy shaped like a ring with a gem-like top, providing a sweet treat in a fun, wearable form.
2 Tootsie Pops
Hard candy lollipops with a chewy chocolate center.
Whirly PoP 1.5oz
A colorful, swirled lollipop typically enjoyed for its sweet and fruity flavors.
Kit Kat
$3.01
Crisp wafers layered with smooth milk chocolate.
Hershey Bar
Creamy milk chocolate bar with a smooth texture and rich cocoa flavor.
12oz Taffy Tub 3/4lb
Coney Waffle 3/4 Pound of Taffy
Pop Corn Tub
$2.73
Freshly-popped corn in a convenient tub, typically enjoyed as a light and crunchy treat.
Vegan / 100% Dairy Lactose Free
A robust selection of plant-based frozen deserts, crafted with non-dairy ingredients, offering a flavorful experience that celebrates the richness of NON-DAIRY treats. NO ANIMAL PRODUCTS!
Drinks
$3.28
Stewarts, Classics, Coke, Pepsi, Gatorade, Sprite, Orange, Fanta, Dr Pepper
Cookies -n- Cream Hot Chocolate
$6.57
Velvety smooth hot chocolate infused with cookies and cream, delivering a rich and creamy texture in every sip.
Hot Spiced Apple Cider
Warm apple cider infused with a blend of cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg, offering a cozy and aromatic beverage perfect for chilly days.
Hot Chocolate
A rich and creamy hot chocolate, made with premium cocoa and steamed milk, optionally topped with fluffy marshmallows.
Water
$2.92
Poland Spring Sport Top
REESE'S Peanut Butter Cake
$52.67
2 layers of VANILLA PEANUT BUTTER or CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, sprinkles, crushed Reese's, and Reese's pieces!
MONSTER BLUE Cookie Cake
$63.36
A 6-inch round cake with 2 layers of MONSTER BLUE ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with SIX ice cream sandwiches, topped with Oreos, mini chocolate chip cookies, and blue sprinkles!
KIT KAT Cake
$81.50
2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, wrapped in Kit Kats, topped with ice cream sandwiches, mini M&M',s and chocolate covered pretzels!
NUTELLA Drip Cake
$75.61
8-inch ice cream cake made of 2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, topped with a chocolate fudge drip, decorated with chocolate sprinkles, mini Nutella jars, Ferrero Rochers, and an assortment of chocolate bars!
Oreo Ice Cream Cake
$51.30
2 layers of COOKIES & CREAM ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, topped with Oreo ice cream sandwiches rolled with rainbow sprinkles, and loaded with crushed Oreos! Need a larger cake? Order a Coney Waffle Sheet Cake here: https://www.coneywaffle.com/product/coney-waffle-sheet-cakes/508?cp=true&sa=false&sbp=false&q=false&category_id=2
S'MORES Ice Cream Cake
$73.79
8-inch cake make of 2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, a chocolate drip, marshmallows, crushed graham crackers, and more chocolate!
Cannoli Ice Cream Cake
$65.83
An 8 inch cake with 2 layers of CANNOLI ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, topped with ice cream sandwiches, decorated with cannoli shells and mini chocolate chips!
Strawberry Shortcake Ice Cream Cake
An 8 inch cake with 2 layers of STRAWBERRY ice cream filled with a layer of white cake crunch, topped with ice cream sandwiches, decorated with cheesecake bites and strawberry shortcake crumbs! **NOTE: Additional toppings available for an additional charge.
CHOCOLATE FUDGE Brownie Cake
8-inch cake made of 2 layers of CHOCOLATE FUDGE BROWNIE ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, chocolate cake crunch, brownie bites, and mini chocolate chips!
ICE CREAM Sandwich Pull-Apart Cake
$37.31
A tower of ice cream sandwiches for your guests to pull-apart and enjoy! A mix of Vanilla Oreo and Vanilla Chocolate Chip ice cream sandwiches
MINI Ice Cream Cake
$21.04
A 4-inch Mini Ice Cream Cake made of two layers of ice cream and chocolate cake crunch. Serves 1-2.
Ice Cream Sampler Plate
$47.18
A variety of sample slices of our most popular ice cream flavors! Toppings and ice cream flavors will vary per order based on availability.
CANDY Ice Cream Cake
8-inch ice cream cake made of 2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with a chocolate fudge drip, ice cream sandwiches, rainbow sprinkles, and an assortment of chocolate and gummy candies!
PULL Apart Cake
$67.20
6-inch cake made of 2 layers of ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches around the cake, and rainbow sprinkles!
COOKIE Dough Oreo Mix Cake
Cookie Dough Oreo Mix Ice Cream Cake - 2 layers of COOKIE DOUGH or COOKIES & CREAM ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, cookie dough, and crushed Oreo cookies!
Cookie Dough Ice Cream Cake
2 layers of COOKIE DOUGH ice cream filled with a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with ice cream sandwiches, and loads of cookie dough! Need a larger cake? Order a Coney Waffle Sheet Cake here: https://www.coneywaffle.com/product/coney-waffle-sheet-cakes/508?cp=true&sa=false&sbp=false&q=false&category_id=2
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: