Full menu
Tiff's Trio® Box (Sampler)
$16.50
1 Salted Caramel Blondie, 1 Fudge Brownie, & 1 Peanut Butter Chocolate Bar
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie + Vanilla Bean Pint
$23.00
For a shareable deep dish cookie and ice cream treat! This dessert leaves nothing out. Includes 1 six inch Cookie Pie with a pint of vanilla bean ice cream. Perfectly sized for 2-3 people.
Cookie Pie & Ice Cream
For a shareable deep dish cookie and ice cream treat! This dessert leaves nothing out. Includes 1 six inch Cookie Pie with a choice of ice cream pint. Perfectly sized for 2-3 people.
Fudge Brownie
$5.50
Classic chocolate fudge brownie topped with chocolate chips.
Cookie Truffles (4-Pack)
$18.00
Box of 4 ready-to-eat chocolate chip cookie dough balls, rolled up and mixed with crunchy toffee bits, hand dipped in dark chocolate and topped with white and gold sprinkles.
Tiff's Trio® + Cookies Combo
$42.50
For the adventurous one who likes to try a little of everything. Enough for sharing with a small group. Includes 1 dozen cookies and 1 Tiff's Trio® box: includes peanut butter chocolate bar, traditional chocolate fudge brownie, & salted caramel blondie in a white gift box.
1 Dozen Warm Cookies
$26.00
1 dozen cookies
2 Dozen Warm Cookies
$52.00
2 dozen cookies
Individually Wrapped Cookie Box
$33.00
For quick and easy take-away favors at your event or solving snack duty at the soccer field without the hassle or mess. Includes 12 individually wrapped cookies in a gift box. One flavor selection per box.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
$14.00
For the ultimate shareable treat! Our Cookie Pie is just that - a giant, extra gooey cookie meant to be enjoyed with a spoon! Six inches in diameter, this deep dish goodie arrives warm and pairs wonderfully with ice cream or frosting. Perfectly sized for 2-3 people.
Birthday Confetti Cookie Pie
Double Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie
Snickerdoodle Cookie Pie
Birthday Confetti Pie + Vanilla Bean Pint
Double Chocolate Chip Pie + Vanilla Bean Pint
Snickerdoodle Pie + Vanilla Bean Pint
Birthday Gift Bow for Cookie Pie
$3.50
Add this Birthday Gift Bow to your choice of Cookie Pie to make the perfect birthday gift. Cookie Pie not included. Must add Cookie Pie to cart separately.
Half Dozen — Tiff's Mix® (Variety)
$13.00
A selection of chocolate chip, sugar with M&M's®, double chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, & snickerdoodle cookies. Sorry, no substitutions! Flavors may vary by store.
Half Dozen — Sugar Cookie with M&M's®
Signature sugar cookie packed with colorful M&M's® candy
Half Dozen — Classic Chocolate Chip
Original recipe with melty semi-sweet chocolate chips
Half Dozen — Snickerdoodle
Buttery and soft cookie dusted with cinnamon and sugar
Half Dozen — Pecan Chocolate Chip
Classic chocolate chip cookie with crunchy pecans
Half Dozen — Sugar
Signature warm and buttery cookie sprinkled with sugar
Half Dozen — Birthday Confetti
A festive and colorful sugar cookie baked with confetti sprinkles and white chips, which all comes together to taste just like birthday cake.
Half Dozen — Double Chocolate Chip
Chocolate cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips
Half Dozen — Peanut Butter
Nutty and sweet with peanut butter morsels
Half Dozen — Oatmeal Raisin
Plump raisins enveloped in a hearty oatmeal dough
Half Dozen — Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Hearty oatmeal dough with gooey chocolate chips
Half Dozen — Lemon Sugar
Tart and sweet, our Lemon Sugar cookies are refreshingly citrusy and topped with powdered sugar.
Half Dozen — Apple Pie Filled Cookie (LTO)
Inspired by nostalgic apple pie, these cookies are the perfect summer treat. Made with real apples, cinnamon, and oats and topped with sanding sugar.
Half Dozen — Picnic Mix (LTO)
A nostalgic trio of 2 Apple Pie Filled, 2 Snickerdoodle, and 2 M&M cookies, perfect for sunny days and summer moments.
Half Dozen — Matcha Latte (LTO)
A soft-baked matcha cookie made with premium matcha powder, offering delicate floral, earthy notes and studded with creamy white chips.
Salted Caramel Blondie
Blondie bar made with caramel bits, white chocolate chips, walnuts, topped with toffee bits and sea salt.
Frost 'ems® — Chocolate Buttercream
$2.50
Single cup of chocolate buttercream frosting
Frost 'ems® - Vanilla Buttercream
Single cup of vanilla buttercream frosting
Peanut Butter Chocolate Bar
Our famous peanut butter cookies made into a bar, mixed with miniature milk chocolate chips and topped with peanut butter morsels and semi sweet chocolate chips.
Dark Chocolate Ice Cream Pint
$9.00
We blend Republica Del Cacao's cacao powder with 56%25 Ecuadorian dark chocolate to craft an exceptionally rich and distinctive chocolate flavor.
Fudge Brownie Ice Cream w/ Sea Salt Caramel
Creamy Cloud 10 Creamery Vanilla Bean Ice Cream, loaded with Tiff's Treats fudge brownies and swirls of luscious sea salt caramel. A perfectly balanced sweet and salty treat.
Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Pint
Creamy mint ice cream, blended with rich chocolate chips crafted exclusively for Tiff's Treats. A cool & indulgent delight.
Strawberry Sorbet Pint
A refreshing dairy-free treat exclusively for Tiff’s Treats, this fresh strawberry sorbet bursts with the vibrant flavor of ripe, juicy strawberries. Perfectly sweet and delightfully smooth.
Brown Sugar Choc. Chip Cookie Ice Cream w/ Fudge
Indulge in creamy brown sugar ice cream swirled with Tiff's Treats chocolate chip cookies and rich fudge sauce. A decadent, cookie-filled delight in every bite.
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream Pint
Rich Bourbon Madagascar Vanilla Bean, offering deep caramel notes and vanilla bean flecks for a smooth, sophisticated flavor.
Dasani® Water (16.9 oz)
16.9 oz bottle
Coca-Cola® (20 oz)
20 oz bottle
Diet Coke® (20 oz)
1%25 Milk — Half Pint
Milk bottle design may vary.
Chocolate Milk — Half Pint
Classic Thank You Package
$36.00
For sending a simple thank you to show your gratitude. Perfectly sized for one or sharing with a select few. Includes 1 dozen cookies and Thank You gift box & balloon
Classic I Love You Package
For letting someone special know how you feel. Perfectly sized for one, with just enough left to share with you. Includes 1 dozen cookies, I Love You gift box & balloon
Classic Thinking of You Package
For sending your thoughts and well wishes. Perfectly sized for one or sharing with a select few. Includes 1 dozen cookies, Thinking of You gift box & balloon
Classic Birthday Package
A best seller! For the no-nonsense friend who knows exactly what they like. Simple and understated, perfectly sized for one or sharing with a select few. Includes 1 dozen cookies, Birthday gift box & balloon
Total Birthday Package
$40.50
For a birthday gift complete with a special card. Includes 1 dozen cookies, cheerful birthday greeting card with a customizable gift message, Birthday gift box & balloon.
Classic Good Luck Package
For the one you are crossing fingers for but totally know they can pull it off. Perfectly sized for one or sharing with a select few. Includes 1 dozen cookies, Good Luck gift box & balloon
Catering Tray — Small (2 Dozen)
$63.00
For a small group gathering when presentation matters. Cookies arrive warm and perfectly placed on a serving platter, party-ready. Serve immediately or save for later with its air tight lid keeping the cookies fresh all day. Feeds approximately 12-16. Includes 2 dozen cookies on a small 12 inch tray.
Catering Tray — Medium (6 Dozen)
$168.00
For a good sized event or party. Cookies arrive warm and perfectly placed on a serving platter, party-ready for a group. Serve immediately or save for later with its air tight lid keeping the cookies fresh all day. Feeds approximately 36-48. Includes 6 dozen cookies on an 18 inch tray.
Catering Tray — Large (9 Dozen)
$235.00
For a larger event or party. Cookies arrive warm and perfectly placed on a serving platter, party-ready for a large group. Serve immediately or save for later with its air tight lid keeping the cookies fresh all day. Feeds approximately 48-72. Includes 9 dozen cookies on an 18 inch tray.
Catering Tray — Cookies & Brownies
$141.00
For a smaller event or party when you want to have a little variety. Cookies and brownies arrive warm and perfectly placed on a serving platter, party-ready for a group. Feeds approximately 28-36. Includes 3 dozen cookies and 18 brownie halves on an 18 inch tray.
Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies - Box of 36
$31.00
Introducing bite-sized Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies! This box includes three dozen mini cookies baked with rich chocolate chips and perfectly portioned for an easy treat.