Full menu
Special Shake
$8.00
Follow us @BurgatoryBar for the current special!
Burger of the Month
$20.50
Salted Nutella Crunch
Some people are just meant for each other. Nutella & Nestlé Crunch Bars are the shake equivalent. Try it & you’ll fall in love too…Wait, this is starting to get weird.
Caramel Pretzel
A great combination of sweet & salty. It's impossible to take just one sip, so be careful if you decide to share.
Cold Brew Brownie
House Cold Brew Espresso + Just Baked Brownies. Like a great coffee house experience while hanging out in a bar, which is way more fun.
Vanilla
Vegan Peanut Butter
Chocolate
Vegan Vanilla
Strawberry
Vegan Strawberry
Strawberry Pop-Tart
Fresh Strawberries, Crushed Pie Crust & Sprinkles. Like sneaking a Pop Tart before school…except now no one can tell you no.
Vegan Chocolate
Cookie Monster
Monsters unite! the only thing better than dunking chocolate chip cookies in milk is blending them into a shake.
Party Animal
Crushed Iced Animal Crackers & Rainbow Nonpareils. Proceeds from every shake support conservation & rehabilitation efforts at Pittsburgh Zoo & Aquarium.
Oreo Peanut Butter Pie
Oreo. Peanut Butter. Pie. Seriously, is there anything else we need to say here?
Campfire S'mores
All your best memories of summer camp blended into a shake. You may feel the urge to start a sing-a-long. Please refrain.
Truffle Gorgonzola Fries
$11.50
Sea Salt & Herb House Fries tossed with White Truffle Oil & Amish Gorgonzola.
Wicked Wings (8)
$16.00
Pan’s Top Secret 13-Ingredient Dry Spice Rubbed Wings drizzled with Hot Honey Glaze. Perfect combo of sweet & heat. One bite & you’ll be hooked.
Tempura Fried Mozzarella
Four Crispy Hand Battered Mozzarella Triangles with a Parmesan finish Served with Vodka Sauce. Perfect for sharing with the whole congregation.
Wings (8)
Great combination of sweet & heat. Buffalo sauce & bourbon BBQ available for those more traditionally minded.
Pale Ale Onion Rings
Fat brew battered onion rings served with house-made spicy ketchup & chipotle horseradish dipping sauce.
Six Napkin Nachos
$14.00
Tony’s Chicken Chili, Queso, Jack & Cheddar Cheese, Pickled Jalapeño Peppers, Grilled Corn, Shredded Lettuce, Pickled Red Onions & Chipotle Lime Crema. Extra napkins are complimentary.
Caesar Salad
Chopped Romaine, Grated & Shaved Parmesan Cheese, Farmhouse Cheddar Crisps, Crumbled Croutons & House Caesar Dressing.
Sierra Steak Salad
Fire Grilled House Marinated Ribeye layered over Chopped Romaine, Roasted Corn, Grape Tomatoes, Pickled Red Onions, Grated Parmesan & tossed in a bright Herbed Parmesan Dressing.
Sonoma Chopped Chicken Salad
$18.00
Grilled chicken breast, baby spinach & crisp greens, bacon crumbles, hard cooked egg, cucumber, sweet onion, tomato, avocado, red pepper, gorgonzola & herbed croutons with red wine vinaigrette.
Tony's Chicken Chili
Small Batch Chili topped with Grated Farmhouse Cheddar, Chipotle Lime Crema & Diced Sweet Red Onions. Served with warm Jalapeño & Cheddar Cornbread
Standard Deluxe Burger*
$16.50
All natural beef burger with white American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & our house burger sauce. *These items may be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness
Phat Patti's Veggie Burger
$17.00
Ground Cremini Mushrooms, Ancient Grains, Cashews & Local Veggies mixed with a million secret ingredients. Topped with Smoked Salt Gouda, Mixed Greens, Tomato & Avocado on a Whole Wheat Bun.
Meat Your Maker Burger*
Dry Aged Wagyu Beef with Sweet Onion Crust, Sharp Swiss, Roasted Tomatoes, Organic Field Greens & Truffled Shallot Aioli. So good you’ll think you died & went to heaven. *These items may be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness
Chippy Chick Chicken Burger
$18.25
Potato Chip Crusted Ground Chicken Burger with Farmhouse Cheddar, Bacon, Onion Straws & Honey Mustard on a Pretzel Bun.
The Impossible Burger
Impossible Burger topped with White American Cheese, Crisp Iceberg, Tomato, Red Onion, Dill Pickles & Naughty Sauce on a Potato Bun. A devilishly good burger experience without the meat.
Piggy Butter & Jelly Burger
$19.50
Cajun dusted ground beef & ground bacon burger with white American cheese, candied bacon, bread & butter pickles, peanut butter & habanero jelly. *Please note because this burger is half ground bacon it will always appear pink in the center even when it is fully cooked to 165 degrees.
Morty's Steakhouse Burger
$19.25
Peppercorn crusted beef with horseradish cheddar, caramelized onions, haystack onions & au poivre sauce. Like the greatest steak dinner you've ever had reincarnated as a burger. * *These items may be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness
Jalapeno Popper Smash Burger
Two Griddled Smash Burgers with Cheddar Jack Cheese, Griddled Onions, Queso, Pickled Jalapeños, Bacon & Candied Jalapeno Relish on a Potato Bun.
Double Smash Burger*
Two Griddled Smash Burgers with Double White American Cheese, Griddled Onions, Naughty Sauce, Dill Pickles & Bacon on a Potato Bun. *These items may be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness
BBQ Bison*
BBQ Crusted Bison with Farmhouse Cheddar, Bacon, Tomato, Bread & Butter Pickles, Picked Red Onions & Honey Mustard on Brioche. *These items may be cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness
Au Poivre Smash Burger
Two Griddled Smash Burgers with Swiss Cheese, Grilled Onions, Mushrooms, Au Poivre Sauce & Garlic Mayo on a Potato Bun.
Natural Bison
$17.50
Please enter a name for your creation in the Extra Instructions field!
Impossible Burger
Dry Aged Wagyu
Vegan Veggie
$15.50
Contains cashews. Please enter a name for your creation in the Extra Instructions field!
Fiddy-Fiddy
Please enter a name for your creation in the Extra Instructions field! Fiddy-fiddy (ground beef & ground bacon). *Please note because this burger is half ground bacon it will always appear pink in the center even when it is fully cooked to 165 degrees.
Hormone Free Beef
Please enter a name your creation in the Extra Instructions field!
Grilled Chicken Breast
All Natural Ground Chicken
$15.00
WTF Chicken Sandwich
Our “What The Fried” Chicken is topped with Shredded Iceberg, Dill Pickles & Naught Sauce on Brioche. One bite & you’ll get the name! Served with lightly dressed field greens.
Hot Honey BBQ Chicken
Local Amish Fried Chicken dipped in Hot Honey BBQ with Bread & Butter Pickles, Shredded Lettuce & Mayo in Brioche. Served with Lightly Dressed Field Greens.
Sea Salt & Herb Fries
Smoked Pepper Baked Beans
$5.00
Side of Sauce
Roasted Potato Salad
$6.50
Lil' Simple Green Salad
Baked Fresh Jalapeño Cheddar Cornbread
With sweet honey butter.
Grilled Cheese
$9.00
Gooey American cheese on griddled home-style bread.
Kids Burger Deluxe
Single Smash with American Cheese.
Foghorn's Fried Chicken
All natural chicken breast tenders.
Mac & Cheese
Creamy Yellow Cheddar Noodles
Berry Lemonade
Arnold Palmer
Coke
$4.00
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Apple Juice Box
$2.50
Iced Tea
Ginger Ale
Diet Coke
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Sprite
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
Bottled Natrona Ginger Beer
Sweet Tea
Bottled Natrona Root Beer
Cranberry Juice
Cherry Coke
Enjoy the crisp and refreshing taste with sweet, smooth cherry flavor.
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: