Full menu
Georgia Peach Pie
$45.00
A medley of sweet, local Georgia peaches picked at their peak of flavor, and baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter lattice pie crust. We purchase our peaches from local, Georgia Grown farms.
Key Lime Pie
Our Key Lime Pie is the perfect dessert to cool off with on a hot summer day. Made with fresh squeezed key lime juice and topped with dollops of fresh cream inside a homemade graham cracker crust. Perfect balance of tart citrus and sweetness. This pie comes FROZEN - keep frozen until you are ready to cut and serve.
Chocolate Chess Pie
$40.00
A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell!
Traditional Apple Pie
Locally grown and harvested apples, sprinkled with warm spices and baked to their peak of flavor inside our signature, all-butter crust.
Cherry Pie
Bursting with sour cherries and full of flavor, our cherry pies are the perfect combination of both tart and sweet crowned with an old-fashion lattice, all butter crust.
French Coconut Pie
Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.
Sugar Cream Celebration Pie
Birthday cake batter flavor in pie… yes, please!! This sweet and silky custard is made with cake batter filling, festive sprinkles, and topped with our signature, buttercream frosting. This pie is perfect for any occasion or celebration, whether it be a birthday, work promotion, anniversary, or “just because”! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight.
Signature Buttermilk Pie
This custard pie is baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg in our signature, all-butter crust. Very similar to a chess pie or crème brulee. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery.
Caramel Pecan Pie
Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine.
Tomato Pie
$47.00
Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust.
Chicken Ranchero Pie
Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie!
Southwestern Taco Pie
A combination of our homemade taco seasoning, and hardy ground beef filling paired with black beans, bell peppers and green chilies.
Vegetable Pot Pie
Introducing our Vegetable Pot Pie – a medley of peas, carrots, potatoes, and onions, seasoned to perfection. Enjoy a burst of garden-fresh goodness, mixed with a house-made roux, stuffed in a double all-butter crust.
Spinach Mushroom Quiche
Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day.
Pot Roast Pie
A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust.
Chicken Pot Pie
Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust.
Quiche Lorraine
Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. For busy weeknights, weekend brunches, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration.
$15.00
Made with Springer Mountain Farms chicken, our traditional recipe also includes peas and carrots, salt, pepper, and a rich, homemade roux. This pie is double crusted inside of our all butter pie crust. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
A savory combination of slow cooked pot roast and gravy placed on a bed of creamy mashed potatoes, and baked to perfection in our signature all-butter crust. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
When you know you know a true southern delicacy of vine-ripened tomatoes, sweet georgia onions, and a blend of savory cheeses, baked to perfection in our handmade signature, all-butter crust. for busy weeknights, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
Contains Springer Mountain Farms, sour cream, freshly grated extra sharp cheddar cheese, chopped green chilies, corn, light Mexican seasoning. It is a southwest twist to our chicken pot pie! Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
Elevating taco tuesday and delivering a delicious homemade supper in minutes. our special homemade taco seasoning and hearty beef and black bean filling with corn, tomatoes, and mild green chilies baked in our homemade signature, all-butter crust. for busy weeknights, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
$12.95
Amanda’s mother-in-law’s heirloom recipe that started it all a velvety custard pie, baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg, in our signature, handmade all-butter crust. for holidays, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. For busy weeknights, weekend brunches, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
An award-winning addition - the caramel our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of freshly shelled roasted georgia pecans, in our signature, handmade all-butter crust. for holidays, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
A medley of sweet, local Georgia peaches picked at their peak of flavor, and baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter lattice pie crust. We purchase our peaches from local, Georgia Grown farmers. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
Morning, noon, or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses, and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers any time of day. for busy weeknights, weekend brunches, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
Introducing our Veggie Pot Pie – a medley of peas, carrots, potatoes, and onions, seasoned to perfection. Enjoy a burst of garden-fresh goodness, mixed with a house-made roux, stuffed in a double all-butter crust.
A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell! Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
Pretty on display and decadent to dig into a rich custard, filled with toasted sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, handmade all-butter crust. for holidays, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful gift, all of our pies are handcrafted and beautifully packaged to make every occasion an effortless celebration. Pies are 5" in diameter and serve 1-2.
Cherry Hand Pie
$6.00
Sweet cherry filling in a flaky pastry crust.
Apple Hand Pie
Apple hand pie, filled with sweet, tart apple chunks.
Yeast Cinnamon Rolls
$24.95
Southern Baked Cinnamon rolls are lovingly made the old-fashioned way, a single batch at a time. Our cinnamon rolls are made with yeast and real butter. Light, doughy, and simply delicious – and so good that you will crave more than just one! Delivered frozen in a pan of 8. Thaw on counter for 1 hour or overnight in fridge and warm in oven for 9-12 minutes at 325 degrees. Ice and enjoy!
Sticky Buns
Warm, buttery, and topped with toasted pecans. Our Sticky Buns are baked until golden and finished with a rich brown sugar glaze that melts into every bite. The pecans on top add just the right crunch against a soft, tender center, creating that perfect balance of sweet and satisfying. Serve them warm for an easy, crowd-pleasing treat that feels just a little extra special.
10" Gluten Free Caramel Pecan Pie
One of our signature flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
10" Gluten Free Quiche Lorraine
$52.00
One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, Swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
5" Gluten Free Caramel Pecan Pie
One of our signature flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1 hour or in fridge overnight. Our family’s version of the perfect pecan pie, chock-full of roasted, whole mammoth Georgia pecans, in our signature, all-butter crust. This pie has been featured in Garden and Gun as a top gift to give. It was also featured in O Magazine. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
5" Gluten Free Chocolate Chess Pie
One of our signature flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1 hour or in fridge overnight. A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell! **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
5" Gluten Free French Coconut Pie
One of our Signature Flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1 hour or in fridge overnight. Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
5" Gluten Free Spinach & Mushroom Quiche
$18.00
One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1 hour or in fridge overnight. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
10" Gluten Free Spinach & Mushroom Quiche
One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled with sautéed spinach and mushrooms, freshly shredded cheeses and eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
10" Gluten Free Tomato Pie
One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
5" Gluten Free Quiche Lorraine
One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1 hour or in fridge overnight. Morning, noon or night, a memorable meal maker ready in just minutes. Our signature handmade all-butter crust filled a blend of fresh bacon, sautéed onions, Swiss cheese, and farm fresh eggs to make a delicious, savory custard that delivers anytime of day. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
5" Gluten Free Tomato Pie
One of your favorites, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1 hour or in fridge overnight. Vine-ripened tomatoes and a blend of freshly grated savory cheeses, fresh pressed garlic, and sautéed onions, baked in our signature, all-butter crust. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
10" Gluten Free Chocolate Chess Pie
One of our signature flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. A decadent, gourmet chocolate treat, baked to perfection in our signature, all-butter crust. Tastes just like a brownie in a pie shell! **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
10" Gluten Free French Coconut Pie
One of our Signature Flavors, available in Gluten Free! Comes frozen & can be thawed on counter for 1-2 hours or in fridge overnight. Rich custard pie, filled with sweet coconut shavings and baked in our signature, all-butter crust. We use fresh, local buttermilk made in Gainesville, Georgia in this pie from Mountain Fresh Creamery. **Please note Gluten Free pies come frozen
Sprite (Can)
$2.00
Sprite: A lemon-lime flavored carbonated beverage, known for its crisp, clean taste and refreshing bubbly nature.
Bottled Water
$2.50
A simple, refreshing bottled water to quench your thirst.
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water
$3.25
San Pellegrino sparkling water features gentle bubbles and a balanced mineral profile, offering a refreshing and crisp taste.
Coke (Can)
Coca-cola in a can, offering the classic and effervescent taste of this iconic carbonated beverage.
Diet Coke (Can)
Diet Coke, a zero-calorie cola, offers the classic taste without sugar in a convenient can, delivering a refreshing soda experience.
4-Pack Petite Savory Pies
$60.00
Switch things up with hearty, filling, single-serve meals! With our 4 pack savory, you don’t have to choose - you can have all of your favorites, including Chicken Pot Pie, Chicken Ranchero, Pot Roast Pie, & Tomato Pie! Order hot and ready for dinner or order frozen to have on hand for up to 6 months!
Southern Supper Box
$135.00
Your No-Prep Meal Kit! Pick your favorite 3 dinner pies and check 3 meals off your list this month. Pies store in the freezer for up to 6 months and no thawing is required to bake. Pies are 10 inches in diameter and serve 8 - 10 slices.
Celebration Box
$70.00
Celebrate all of life's special moments with the new Celebration Box! This delightful set features your choice of a delicious sweet pie, made with the finest ingredients and baked to perfection. Enjoy the added treat of the NEW Chocolate Chip Cookies, made with love & care. And to add a pop of fun to your celebration, indulge in a bag of our festive celebration gourmet popcorn. Whether you're marking a birthday, anniversary, or simply celebrating life, this box makes it easy to help you Celebrate Life with Pie!
Gluten Free Box
Featuring a choice of three delicious gluten-free pies from a selection of seven flavorful options, both savory and sweet. PLEASE NOTE GLUTEN-FREE PIES MAY BE FROZEN
Pie Sampler Box
$120.00
Delight your taste buds with our Pie Sampler Box. Choose three of your favorite dessert pies, creating a spread that caters to every craving.
Breakfast Box
$119.00
Introducing our Breakfast Box—an irresistible, hassle-free feast designed to elevate your mornings. Indulge in the heavenly sweetness of freshly baked Old-Fashioned Cinnamon Rolls, paired perfectly with the savory elegance of a classic Quiche Lorraine and the rich goodness of a Spinach & Mushroom Quiche.
Comfort & Care Package
$125.00
Introducing our Comfort & Care Package, the perfect way to show someone you care! This thoughtful package includes a 4-pack of frozen petite savory pies, a 4-pack of petite sweet pies, and a box of our NEW Chocolate Chip Cookies made with semi-sweet chocolate chips and mixed with swirls of toffee & slivers of almonds. Whether you're looking to treat yourself or send some love to a friend or family member, this package is sure to bring comfort and joy. It's a delicious and convenient way to indulge in a variety of flavors, making it the ultimate gift of warmth and comfort.
Grandparent Gift Box
$110.00
What's a grandparent's favorite treat? Petites! Give the gift of ease, variety, and joy with the Grandparent Gift Box - a delectable assortment for them to stock their freezer & enjoy any time. A petite variety pack of 4 sweet and 4 savory pies - gifting them 4 no-prep, no-waste meals; and 4 guilt-free desserts! They'll think of you every time they take a delicious bite! Sweet Pie 4 Pack: Caramel Pecan, Chocolate Chess, French Coconut Custard, and Signature Buttermilk Savory Take & Bake Pie 4 Pack: Chicken Pot Pie, Southwestern Taco, Tomato, and Pot Roast Pie
Deluxe Grandparent Gift Box
$195.00
Introducing our Deluxe Grandparent Gift Box, a delightful selection that's sure to warm the hearts and tummies of beloved grandparents! This thoughtful gift includes a 4-pack of frozen petite savory pies, a 4-pack of petite sweet pies, a 4-pack of frozen petite quiches, and a pack of delicious Old-Fashioned Cinnamon Rolls. This box isn't just a collection of delicious treats—it's a gesture of love and appreciation that brings joy to the special grandparents in your life. Plus, with its variety of flavors and options, it's sure to please even the pickiest of palates!
New Home Owner Gift Set
This thoughtful box includes your choice of a dinner pie, choice of a dessert, and an exclusive SBP X Heirloomed candle. Whether you're congratulating someone on their new space or settling into your new home, this gift set is the perfect way to add warmth and comfort to any new abode. It's a thoughtful and practical gift that brings the delicious flavors of Southern Baked Pie Company and the cozy ambiance of a candlelit home to life.
Deluxe New Home Owner Gift Set
$154.00
Introducing our Deluxe New Home Owner Gift Set, a delicious collection to celebrate new beginnings! This set includes your choice of a dinner pie, a dessert pie, and choice of quiche, along with an Heirloomed Co. tea towel. Whether you're welcoming someone to their new home or treating yourself to a fresh start, this gift set is the perfect blend of comfort and elegance.
4 Pack Petite Pie Bundle
$49.95
Bundle & Save! Our 4 pack sweet pie bundle makes a great gift and is the perfect way to sample our favorite flavors!
Dinner & Dessert Box
$85.00
Cross dinner & dessert off the list... we have it covered! This bundle features your choice of our most popular sweet pies and savory dinner pies. It also makes a wonderful gift for the person who just needs a meal taken off their plate! Please choose your savory pie (Take & Bake comes FROZEN and you can bake it at home or choose Baked if you'd like us to bake it for you in store) and your favorite sweet pie below.
"Pie Purse" Insulated Cooler Bag
$35.00
She’s stylish, she’s tough, she’s beautiful…she’s the Pie Purse! This bag has it all: -Holds up to 4 pies -Insulated to keep contents warm or cold -Water resistant -Travels beautifully -Stylish, soft, and durable design
Perfect Slice Pie Cutter
$24.00
Cutting a uniform pie slice is no easy task, but our perfect pie slicer makes the process easy as pie. Simply slice through your pie and serve a uniform piece to guests every time. This stainless steel cutter features a 10" diameter ring with eight, 2" high blades.
Perfect Slice Pie Marker
Ensure that when serving pies they look the best they can by using this 8 cut pie marker which makes sure that every piece of pie is a perfect, even size. Our pie marker can also be used to mark the tops of pies, cakes, or cheesecakes to ensure slices are evenly cut. Marks 8 perfect, uniform slices.
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: