Full menu
Wake up in Brooklyn Brunch
$106.99
Heading out of town for the weekend? Hamptons? Berkshires? Down the shore? For 2-4 people. 1/2 lb. Hand-sliced eastern Gaspe Nova. 6 Assorted Shelsky’s Brooklyn old-fashioned toasting bagels. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s plain cream cheese. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s scallion cream cheese. 12 oz. Ashlawn Farm Daterra Villa Borghese (medium roast, single plantation Rainforest Alliance Certified coffee). 1 lb. Shelsky’s assorted homemade rugelach
How You Doin’ Brunch
$165.99
Heading out of town for the weekend? Hamptons? Berkshires? Down the shore? For 8 people. 1/2 lb. Hand-sliced mild Scottish smoked salmon. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s Hand-sliced house-cured gravlax. 10 Assorted Shelsky’s Brooklyn old-fashioned toasting bagels. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s plain cream cheese. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s scallion cream cheese. 1 Shelsky’s Homemade chocolate babka. 1 lb, Shelsky’s assorted homemade rugelach. 12 oz. Ashlawn Farm Daterra Villa Borghese (medium roast, single plantation Rainforest
Big Macher Brooklyn Brunch
$225.99
Heading out of town for the weekend? Hamptons? Berkshires? Down the shore? For 12 people. 1/2 lb. Hand-sliced buttery king smoked salmon. 1/2 lb. Hand-sliced wild Alaskan sable (black cod). 2 Sliced fillets of Shelsky’s pickled herring with your choice of cream sauce and onions or wine sauce and onions. 1/2 lb. Hand-sliced mild Scottish smoked salmon. A dozen assorted Shelsky’s Brooklyn old-fashioned toasting bagels. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s smoked whitefish salad. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s homemade chopped l
A Brooklyn Schmear Brunch
$90.99
Heading out of town for the weekend? Hamptons? Berkshires? Down the shore? Bring some Brooklyn bagels and schmears with you! For 6-8 people. A dozen assorted Shelsky’s Brooklyn old-fashioned toasting bagels. ½ lb. Shelsky’s plain cream cheese. ½ lb. Shelsky’s scallion cream cheese. ½ lb. Shelsky’s lox cream cheese. ½ lb. Shelsky’s vegetable cream cheese. ½ lb. Shelsky’s smoked whitefish salad
Cardiologists Dream Brunch
$96.99
Heading out of town for the weekend? Hamptons? Berkshires? Down the shore? For 4 people. 1/2 lb. full loaf sliced rye (your choice of plain or seeded). 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s deli pastrami. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s deli corned beef. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s slowly roasted roast beef. Spicy brown deli mustard. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s deli coleslaw. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s Riesling-braised sauerkraut. 1/2 lb. Shelsky’s deli potato salad
The Great Gatsby
$19.99
Pastrami-smoked salmon, honey mustard, horseradish cream cheese and thinly-sliced red onion. We invented the sandwich on seeded rye. We suggest it on seeded rye. But, feel free to make a different bread choice. It's your sandwich. But, we're right. Just sayin'!
The Fancy Pants
$24.49
Lake sturgeon, house-cured gravlax, cream cheese, tomato and red onion. Served on your choice of bagel or rye bread.
The Tribute
$22.99
Our AWESOME smoked whitefish salad, horseradish cream cheese, and wasabi tobiko. Served on your choice of bread.
Brooklyn Native
$20.99
Eastern Gaspe Nova, smoked whitefish salad, pickled herring and sour pickles served with your choice of bagel or bialy.
The Tuna Spicy Super Funk
$17.99
Shelsky's seriously great tuna salad. Served on a bed sliced jalapenos, topped with Malaysian chili sambal (contains fermented shrimp paste) and crispy Chinatown fried onions. Served on your choice of bread. *WARNING - THIS SANDWICH IS SPICY. WE'RE NOT JOKING.
Shelsky's Pastrami (Pastrami Smoked Salmon)
Pastrami-smoked salmon, mustard herring and riesling-braised sauerkraut. Served on your choice of bread.
The Turboff
Baked salmon salad, hand-sliced Eastern Gaspe Nova, horseradish cream cheese, tomatoes, thinly-sliced red onions, capers, and lemon juice. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.
Osetra's Momma
$21.49
California lake sturgeon, butter, and thinly-sliced red onion. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.
The Newhouse
Hand-sliced wild Alaskan sable, scallion cream cheese, and tomatoes. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.
The Holy Mackerel
$14.99
Smoked peppered mackerel, vegetable cream cheese, and cucumber salad. Served on your choice of bagel or rye bread.
The Clementine
$20.49
House-cured gravlax, butter, thinly-sliced red onion, tomatoes, capers, and lemon juice. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.
Spicy Shrimp Roll
$16.49
Spicy shrimp salad with Kewpie brand Japanese mayo, masago, togarashi and sesame oil. We invented this sandwich on an Orwasher's Bakery onion roll. We REALLY think you should have it on one of those! But, it's your sandwich, so you decide. Trust us though!
The Fishless
$12.49
Tomatoes, pickled tomatoes, cilantro, jalapeños, thinly-sliced red onions, apple horseradish sauce, and mayonnaise. Served on your choice of bread.
Brooklyn Transplant
Rich and silky kippered salmon, apple horseradish sauce, plain cream cheese and pickled herring salad. Served on your choice of bread.
The Spicy Red or White
$17.49
Our American dream series... Your choice of baked salmon salad (red), OR smoked whitefish salad (white) topped with cucumber salad and sriracha hot sauce. Served on your choice of bread.
El Vicente
$23.49
Lake sturgeon, plain cream cheese, fresh jalapeños, sour pickles, and tomato. Served on your choice of bread.
Member of the Tribe
$18.99
The classic - Eastern Gaspe Nova, and your choice of scallion or plain cream cheese. Served on your choice of bagel or bialy.
Peter Shelsky
Eastern Gaspe Nova, wild-Alaskan sable, pickled herring with cream sauce and onions, and scallion cream cheese. Served on your choice of bagel or bialy. (Peter invented it on a bialy. It's a mess. BUT SO WORTH THE MESS!)
Seriously Great Tuna Salad On a Bread
$13.99
We're not joking. Our tuna salad is seriously great. Have a tuna sandwich. When was the lost time you just had a tuna sandwich. Go for it. It's a classic done right.
Chicken Salad with Pecans, Grapes & Celery On a Bread
We take extra care to gently poach our chicken for this salad, ensuring that each cube of chicken is moist and juicy! Served on your choice of bread. (yeah, we said moist... sorry, not sorry)
Egg Salad with Cornichons On a Bread
$12.99
Our egg salad has little disks of cornichons (pickled gherkins) in it. Served on your choice of bread.
Chopped Chicken Liver On Bread
$15.99
We hand-chop our chicken livers and gently fold them with duck fat, hard-cooked eggs, and sautéed onions. Cognac rounds it out to make it the perfect chopped liver. Served on your choice of bread.
Pickled Herring Salad On a Bread
Our pickled herring salad is brown. It isn't pretty. But it's SO TASTY! It's great with some butter and thinly-sliced red onion. Served on your choice bread.
Smoked Whitefish Salad with Cucumber & Celery On a Bread
Our smoky whitefish salad works beautifully with the gentle sweetness of our chewy bagels. It is also perfect on a bialy.
Baked Salmon Salad On a Bread
Our baked salmon salad is RICH, and if your are absolutely fah-mished, then having it on a bagel or bialy will totally satisfy you!
Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese
$7.49
Bagel with scallion cream cheese Choice of various bagels or bialys, gluten-free options available. Customize with preferred toasting level.
Bagel with Vegetable Cream Cheese
$8.99
Various bagel or bialy options smeared with vegetable cream cheese. Choose from varieties like everything, plain, sesame, and more. Toasting preferences available.
Bagel with Lox Cream Cheese
$9.49
Bagel with lox cream cheese Choice of bagels including classics, whole wheat, bialys, gluten-free. Options to have it toasted, lightly toasted, or dark toasted.
Bagel with Chili Crisp Cream Cheese
Chili crisp cream cheese spread on your choice of bagels or bialys. Multiple bread, including gluten-free, and preparation options available.
Bagel with Vegan Stockeld Cream Cheese
$8.49
Bagel with vegan Stockeld cream cheese. Choice of over 15 bread varieties, including gluten-free options. Select your preferred toasting level: standard, dark, or lightly toasted.
Bagel with Horseradish Cream Cheese
Horseradish cream cheese on your choice of bagel or bread. Over fifteen varieties of bagels available, including gluten-free. Option to select your preferred level of toasting.
Sichuan Chili Crisp Cream Cheese on A Bagel or Bialy
We blend Laoganma, (angry lady sauce aka spicy chili crisp) with cream cheese. It's loaded with chilies, soy nuts, fried onions, Sichuan peppercorns, and msg. IT. IS. AWESOME.
Bagel with Vegan Stockeld Scallion Cream Cheese
House whipped, fresh scallion with the all natural tofu flavor on your bagel, bialy, or rye bread of your choice
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese
$6.99
Choice of bagel or bread with plain cream cheese. Numerous options including everything, sesame, pumpernickel, and gluten-free. Toasted to your preference.
Bagel with Butter
$4.49
Warm, buttered bagel. Choose from a variety of bagels including garlic, cinnamon raisin, gluten-free, and more. Toasting options: lightly toasted, toasted, dark-toasted, or not toasted.
Shelsky's Reuben Sandwich
$28.99
A hefty pressed sandwich of Shelsky's thinly-sliced hot corned beef, riesling-braised sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing. Served on your choice of Orwasher's Bakery rye or pumpernickel bread.
Shelsky's Roast Turkey Sandwich
Our homemade, thinly-sliced roasted turkey, cole slaw, Swiss cheese, & Russian dressing served on your choice of bread.
Shelskys Roast Beef Roll
We roast Dellapietra's beef rounds slowly to a beautifully rosy-pink medium-rare. We then thinly slice it and gently fold it onto an Orwasher's Bakery onion roll with butter, Dijon mustard, and crispy fried Chinese onions. It's definitely best on that roll, but we're happy to serve it on your choice of bread.
Corned Tongue Sandwich
$23.99
Our corned beef tongue is pickled for 2 weeks before being gently simmered for 4 hours. A personal favorite of Peter Shelsky himself, we thinly slice the tongue and nestle it on your choice of Orwasher's Bakery rye or pumpernickel bread.
Shelsky's Hot Pastrami Sandwich
$27.99
Shelsky's thinly-sliced, super moist pastrami, served hot with brown deli mustard on your choice of Orwasher's Bakery rye or pumpernickel bread.
Shelsky's Hot Corned Beef Sandwich
$26.99
Shelsky's thinly-sliced corned beef, served hot with brown deli mustard on your choice of Orwasher's rye or pumpernickel bread.
Brets Chévre Piment d’Espelette Potato Chips
(Spicy goat cheese) Ruffled Potato Chips (125g bag)
Brets Pesto and Mozzarella Potato Chips
Ruffled Potato Chips (125g bag)
Brets Aïoli Potato Chips
Ruffled Potato Chips (125g bag) that are lusciously garlicky!
Brets Fromage du Jura Potato Chips
(Comte Cheese) Ruffled Potato Chips (125g bag)
Golden Duck Chili Crab Seaweed Tempura (Singapore)
Chili crab is one of Singapore's national dishes. These chips capture the pleasure of eating chili crab.... but they do it without the mess. No passport needed.
Golden Duck Mala Hot Pot Fragrance Mix (Singapore)
It's no secret that Sichuan food is having a global moment right now. This mix, with its numbing spice, is a snack with one of the main flavor profiles of Sichuan, China. SOOOOOO GOOOD!
Brets Fromage Frais & Fines Herbes Potato Chips
(Fresh cheese and herb) Ruffled Potato Chips (125g bag)
Brets Camembert Potato Chips
Amazing! Like HOW DO THEY DO THAT????
Brets Côte de Bœuf Potato Chips
(Ribeye Steak) Ruffled Potato Chips (125g bag)
Brets “La Croquante” Potato Chips
Crispy Plain Salted Ruffle Potato Chips (125g bag) Potato Chips
Golden Duck Salted Egg Fish Skin Chips (Singapore)
And, when the potato chips blew my mind, these were just THE END! I don't think I've ever eaten a more delicious snack than this bag right here.
Golden Duck Salted Egg Crab Seaweed Tempura (Singapore)
I think it's fair to say that Asian countries.... ALL OF THEM, have the West absolutely beat when it comes to snack flavors. These chips prove that out!
12 Oz Mexican Coke Glass Bottle
$4.99
The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.
12 Oz Diet Coke Can
$3.50
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
12 Oz Dr. Brown's Diet Black Cherry
12 oz can
16.9 Oz Poland Spring Water
Pure, refreshing water sourced from natural springs in a 16.9 oz bottle.
12 Oz Canada Dry Seltzer Can
$2.50
Crisp sparkling seltzer water with a hint of natural flavor, packaged in a 12 oz can.
12 Oz Dr. Brown's Black Cherry
12 Oz Dr. Brown's Root Beer
12 Oz Scheweppes Ginger Ale
Natural ginger flavor with other natural flavors, 12 oz can.
Fentiman's Cola
$5.00
Delicious English Soda
Fentiman's Ginger Beer
Fentiman's Victorian Lemonade
Fentiman's Cherry Cola
Cheer Wine Soda
Southern Style Soda
12 Oz Dr. Brown's Cream Soda
12 Oz Dr. Brown's Diet Cream Soda
Ashlawn Farm Coffee Beans - Shelsky's Roast
$19.49
Price per 12 ounce bag. Brew our awesome coffee in the comfort of your own home. These single plantation Brazilian coffee beans are roasted to a rich medium-dark roast in Connecticut by our friends at Ashlawn Farm.
Large Ashlawn Farm Iced Cold Brew
$5.50
Price per 16oz cup (including ICE). Our cold-brewed iced coffee begins with beans grown in Nicaragua. Roasted locally in Connecticut by our friends at Ashlawn Farm, this dark roast yields iced coffee that tastes as richly of roasted coffee beans as the fragrant beans smell when we open a fresh bag! Oh, and, it's rocket fuel!
Ashlawn Farm Coffee Box
$37.00
Price per 12-cup box. Serving a crowd? Our box of Shelsky's Roast Ashlawn Farm Coffee will properly caffeinate you and eleven more people! Served with cups, lids, sleeves, stirrers, Sugar in the Raw, Sweetener, milk, half and half, and oat milk.
Large Ashlawn Farm Hot Drip Coffee
Price per 16 ounce cup. The Shelsky's Roast is roasted locally in Connecticut by our friends at Ashlawn Farm. This rich, bold roast is medium dark, and the beans are from Dater, a single coffee plantation in Brazil. It's a great morning (or anytime) cup!
Small Ashlawn Farm Hot Drip Coffee
$4.00
Price per 12 ounce cup. The Shelsky's Roast is roasted locally in Connecticut by our friends at Ashlawn Farm. This rich, bold roast is medium dark, and the beans are from Dater, a single coffee plantation in Brazil. It's a great morning (or anytime) cup!
À La Menthe (Mint Green Tea)
$3.00
Green tea with a nice smooth minty finish
Darjeeling Margaret's Hope (Black Tea)
A clean and crisp darjeeling. Perfect for a morning cup of tea
Blue of London (Earl Grey)
A moderately floral earl grey with pronounced bergamot. This earl grey can make any hater, at convert
Bourbon Rooibos
Caffeine free the rich flavor of rooibos is reminiscent of Virginia tobacco with gentle notes of rose, orange blossom, berries and Turkish dates
Genmaicha Yama (Classic Green Tea)
Classic Japanese green tea toasted rice similar to what you be served in a sushi restaurant
Thé Du Hammam (Vert Green Tea)
Green tea with gentle notes of rose, orange blossom, berries and Turkish dates
Mild Scottish Salmon
Price per quarter pound. This slightly firm salmon is mild and silky. Harvested in the cold waters of Scotland, it has a pristinely clean finish.
Ora King Salmon (Organic & Sustainable)
Price per quarter pound. This salmon is VERY gently smoked. It's super mild, and the most buttery salmon we sell. It's just pure salmon butter.
Pastrami Smoked Salmon
Price per quarter pound. Imagine if smoked salmon and pastrami had a love-child with a lovely lingering peppery bite. This salmon is cured with pastrami spices, smoked, and then rubbed with pastrami rub. It's just a party in your mouth!
Homemade Gravlax
Price per quarter pound. Our house-cured gravlax begins with a bath of aquavit and lemon juice. We then cure it slowly with salt, sugar, black pepper and fresh dill. After 3 days, we remove the cure, and pack copious amounts of freshly chopped dill on top of the salmon.
Wild Alaskan Sable
Price per quarter pound. An integral part of any appetizing spread, one smoked sable starts as wild black cod fished from frigid Alaskan waters. It's brined with garlic and paprika. Sable is rich, fatty and delicious
Double Cured Irish Salmon
Price per quarter pound. This salmon is has an assertive smoke that doesn't overwhelm, and it's relatively firm due to the double curing process. Absolutely awesome!
Salty Belly Lox
$15.49
Price per quarter pound. This is O.G. - the real lox! It's salt-cured and not smoked. Some might call it assertively salty. It's safer to say that it's aggressively salty. We love it. If you like salty stuff, you will too. We can't speak to what your urologist might think. It's awesome on a well-toasted bialy with scallion cream cheese and tomato.
Tsar's Cut Balik Salmon
$26.74
Price per quarter pound. This loin center cut of smoked Scottish salmon is pure opulence. Cut thick like sashimi, sliding a piece into your mouth is the gastronomic equivalent of listening to a symphony orchestra play live. Reserved for special occasions, it is beautiful on its own or when paired with caviar, blini, and creme fraiche.
Eastern Gaspe Nova
Price per quarter pound. Rich and assertively flavored, this is the quintessential smoked salmon for a bagel with cream cheese. The standard
New Brunswick Smoked Salmon
$13.49
Price per quarter pound. Silky, rich, and soft with moderate smoke. Don't let the low price fool you. This is one of our favorites!
Wild King Salmon "Bacon"
$24.24
Price per quarter pound.. We are the only purveyors in NYC of this amazing product. Flown in weekly from Seattle, the fatty bellies of the wild king salmon are brined and then hot smoked. Great for snacking or hors d'oeuvres. Truly special
Hot Smoked Bluefish
$23.98
Price per half pound. Bluefish, often pejoratively described as "fishy," when smoked over fruit woods, loses those flavours. What replaces them is a deep and profound smoke. Fished, cured, and smoked in Rhode Island, this stuff is just great!
Peppered Hot Smoked Bluefish
Price per half pound. Bluefish, often pejoratively described as "fishy," when smoked over fruit woods, loses those flavours. What replaces them is a deep and profound smoke. Coated in cracked black pepper, this bluefish is fished, cured, and smoked in Rhode Island, this stuff is just great!
Fancy Lake Sturgeon
$23.74
Price per quarter pound. Earthy and rich, smoked sturgeon is among the meatiest fish available! It's great with butter on a bialy.
Wild-Caught Great Lakes Smoked Whitefish
$41.99
These jumbo smoked whitefish are wild-caught from lake Michigan. They are flaky and moist. Yes, we used that word... again. *Boned-Out still might have a stray bone in it. Please be aware as it can be a choking hazard.
Samaki Smoked Trout Fillets
$16.99
Price per pack. These trout fillets are smoky, flaky, earthy, and ready to eat!
Kippered Salmon
$16.74
Price per quarter pound. Our kippered salmon is cut from whole fillets. This means the belly is still attached lending all of its gloriously rich salmon fat to it. It's truly a pleasure to eat.
Peppered Hot Smoked Salmon
$23.48
Price per half pound. Tranches of rich Scottish salmon are coated with cracked black pepper and smoked over fruit woods. Smoked in individual pieces, this flaky salmon boasts a camp-firey smokiness
Chicken Salad (CONTAINS TREE NUTS)
Price per half pound. We gently poach chickens from our friends at Los Paisanos Butcher Shop. We then break apart the pieces, and toss them with pecans, grapes, and celery. It's just a great chicken salad.
Seriously Great Tuna Salad
Price per half pound. We're not kidding. It really is seriously great!
Quart of Half Sour Pickles
$10.50
Crisp and tangy pickles with a mild brine, offering a refreshing crunch in every bite.
Traditional Cucumber Salad
Price per half pound. Our vinegar-based cucumber salad is the perfect foil to all of that smoked fish you're ordering! It's no wonder that it's a staple on the appetizing table.
Quart of Sour Pickles
Crisp and tangy pickles, brined to perfection, offering a delightful crunch and bold sour flavor.
Egg Salad with Cornichons
Price per half pound. Egg salad can be divisive. You either love it or hate it. We love it. And if you're in that camp, then you'll LOVE ours. It's got little slices of cornichons in it!
Homemade Macaroni Salad
$5.99
Price per half pound. Macaroni salad is part of the holy trinity of delicatessen salads. In fact, it is the only acceptable form of pasta salad. We make ours with a homemade dressing that has a nice little zing to it!
Quart of Pickled Tomatoes
Whole green tomatoes pickled in a brine with mustard seeds.
Citrus-Roasted Beet Salad
Price per half pound. Give your table a pop of color with this citrus and thyme scented roasted beet salad.
Bag of 2 Pickles
Two whole pickles, crisp and briny, packed in a clear bag.
Rice Pudding
Price per half pound. We use arborio rice in our rice pudding! All that starch makes it luscious and creamy! Oh, and we add raisins. We know they're divisive. We love raisins in our rice pudding. If you don't, your opinion is wrong.
Homemade Potato Salad
Price per half pound. I've never met a potato that I didn't like, and potato salad can really never be bad. Well, maybe it can.... But, ours is outstanding!
Classi Deli Coleslaw
Price per half pound. Nothing is worse than sad, flavorless coleslaw. Ok, yes, of course, war, famine, illness, they're all worse... But, you get what I'm sayin'. Our coleslaw though is AWESOME!
Baked Salmon Salad
$20.98
Price per half pound. Made from our rich kippered salmon, this spread is great on a bagel, bialy, or rye bread!
Chopped Liver
$10.49
Price per half pound. We sauté chicken livers with onions, then hand-chop them into a chopped liver that walks the line between smooth and chunky. Duck fat, cognac, and hard-cooked eggs round out our chopped liver. It's got that rich unctuousness that makes it an irresistible classic.
Spicy Shrimp Salad
Price per half pound. We make our spicy shrimp salad with Kewpie brand Japanese mayo, masago, togarashi and sesame oil.
Pickled Herring Salad
$11.99
Price per half pound. Our pickled herring salad may not be the prettiest salad of the bunch, but surely one of the tastiest! In fact, it serves perfectly as a sweet and sour compliment to our smoked whitefish or baked salmon salads. It's basically a party in your mouth.
House Pickled Lox
Price per half pound. We love pickling fish! And, while pickled herring is our most popular, pickled lox also deserves your attention. We start by desalinating our salty belly lox in fresh water for 3 days, then we pickle it wine vinegar and our own blend of spices. Slightly sweet, it's a great side-dish, appetizer or snack. Feeling luxurious? Order it with some cream sauce and pickled onions.
Matzo Ball Soup
Price per quart (2 servings). We simmer chicken bones for 8 hours to make the stock that goes into it! A whole lot of care goes into this rich, soul-affirming soup. Oh, and the matzo balls? They're floaters! *This soup is sold cold, and is meant to be heated in a pot on your stovetop at home.
Smoked Whitefish Salad
Price per half pound. Our smoked whitefish salad is made with wild-caught whitefish from the great lakes. This is not a mayonnaise salad with some fish byproduct. This is a premium whitefish salad dressed with a little mayonnaise. It tastes like smoke and cold-water fresh fish.
Everything Bagel
$2.99
Our plain bagels coated with our own homemade everything topping.
Onion Bialy
$3.99
not for intend for sale as a sandwich, please make sandwich selection in main menu
1 Gluten-Free Everything Bagel
These gluten-free bagels ACTUALLY taste like a bagel!
Egg Bagel
Not your average egg bagel. Made with egg yolks, turmeric, annatto and indian sulfur salt.
Wholewheat Plain Bagel
A whole wheat bagel made whole wheat flour and a mash of rolled and steel cuts oats, hemp seed, flax seed and wheat germ topped with a germ mixture.
Salt Bagel
Our plain bagels coated with pretzel salt.
Sichuan Peppercorn Bagel
(numbing). our plain bagels with numbing zing of imported single plantation sichuan peppercorns mixed into the dough and topped with black and whites sesame seeds.
Garlic Poppy Bialy
Pumpernickel Bagel
A complex chewy bagel with rye flour, coffee and cocoa powder.
Wholewheat Everything Bagel
Our stunning whole wheat bagels topped with everything topping.
Garlic Bagel
Our plain bagels coated with crunchy dried garlic.
Onion Bagel
Our plain bagels coated with dried onion flakes.
Cracked Peppercorn & Salt Bagel
Our plain bagels coated with lots of cracked pepper and pretzel salt. A bagel au poivre.
1 Gluten-Free Plain Bagel
These gluten-free bagels actually taste like bagels! They're chewy and everything!
1 Gluten-Free Sesame Bagel
These gluten free bagels are awesome! They actually taste like bagels.
Sesame Bagel
Our plain bagels coated with sesame seeds and just a touch of pretzel salt.
Poppyseed Bagel
Our plain bagels coated with poppy seeds.
Horseradish Cream Cheeses
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. One brave soul on our team, then puts on a pair of goggles and finely grates a whole bunch of horseradish root. That and a healthy pinch of ground white pepper get folded into the cream cheese. Not gonna lie, it's pretty awesome.
Vegetable Cream Cheese
$9.99
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. We then brunoise red, orange, and yellow bell peppers, and combine them with minced fresh garlic, to make some truly remarkable vegetable cream cheese.
Lox Cream Cheese
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. Ground Nova is whipped into our cream cheese to make this appetizing shop and bagel store classic. As for me? I LOVE it on a poppy seed bagel. But that's me. You do you.
Chili Crisp Cream Cheese
$10.99
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. Then we mix it with Laoganma, A.K.A. spicy chili crisp, A.K.A. angry lady sauce. Sure it's great on a bagel.... Know what else it's great on? A spoon!
Vegan Stockeld® Cream Cheese (made from cultured chickpeas & lentils)
Price per half pound. Perfect for vegans and the lactose challenged among us, unlike tofu cream cheese, this Stockeld® cream cheese doesn't taste and look like spackle. In fact, it's super tasty!
Vegan Stockeld® Scallion Cream Cheese (made from cultured chickpeas & lentils)
Plain Cream Cheese
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy - the perfect spread for a bagel!
Scallion Cream Cheese
Price per half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. We mix it with a whole lot of freshly chopped scallions. It's the perfect spread for a bagel!
Mustard Dill Herring
$4.75
Price per fillet. We marinate our classic pickled herring in a homemade whole grain dijon mustard and fresh dill sauce.
Roll Mops with Sour Pickles
Price per roll mop. Our pickled herring pounded thin and wrapped around full sour pickles.
Roll Mops with Pickled Onions
Price per roll mop. Our pickled herring pounded thin and wrapped around pickled onions.
Schmaltz Herring
$6.00
Price per fillet. Schmaltz herring is velvety salted herring, preserved in oil. Think of it as herring confit. Sorta.
Matjes Herring
$6.25
Price per fllet. Large baby herring fillets are salted and pickled with warming spices and beetroot powder giving them a salty and sweet red hue. Great with some cream cheese and pumpernickel bread.
House Pickled Herring
Price per fillet. The Jewish appetizing shop classic done right, Jumbo salted herring filets are desalinated, and then pickled in wine vinegar with spices and a bit of sugar. Choose from herring in wine sauce or herring with cream and onions.
Homemade Roast Turkey
$18.49
Price per half pound. Sometimes you're just in the mood for some juicy roasted turkey. Our turkey breasts are brined gently and crazy juicy. We slice them thinly.
Classic Delicatessen Corned Beef
Price per half pound. Our briskets are corned with a special blend of spices. A bit leaner than pastrami, the flavor is clean with that nostalgic, jewish deli somethin' somethin'!
Homemade (Corned) Pickled Beef Tongue
Price per half pound. Our beef tongues spend 4 days hanging out in a brine of classic pickling spices. It is then simmered gently for 4 hours. We slice it thinly, and it's absolutely amazing served either hot or cold.
Classic Delicatessen Pastrami
Price per half pound. Brined then rubbed with a special blend of classic pastrami spices, our pastrami is made from the fatty beef navel, and it is slowly smoked and then steamed to tender rich awesomeness.
Homemade Roast Beef
Price per half pound. We brine Dellapietra's rounds for 3 days before dusting them with lots of black pepper and slowly roasting them to a beautiful, rosy, pink medium-rare. We slice it thinly to order.
Seeded Rye Bread (sliced)
Price per 8-slice loaf. This awesome rye bread from Orwasher's Bakery is studded with aromatic caraway seeds.
Round Onion Rolls
Price per 2-pack. These are just a New York classic. The perfect onion rolls. Baked by our friends at Orwasher's Bakery.
Pumpernickel Rye Bread (sliced)
Price per 8-slice loaf. Orwashers pumpernickel rye is some seriously great bread!
Braided Challah
Our braided challahs are gorgeous! And, as beautiful as they are, they're even more delicious. Our challah comes from our friends at Colson Patisserie. Be sure to buy an extra one, so you can let it get stale and make French toast!
Plain Rye Bread (sliced)
Price per 8-slice loaf. Our sliced rye bread comes from the artisans at Orwasher's Bakery.
Baked Potato Knish
This is the standard, old-school, potato-filled knish.
Baked Kasha Knish
These old-school knishes are filled with potato and nutty kasha (buckwheat).
Baked Broccoli Knish
These old school knishes are filled with potato and broccoli.
Fried Square Knish
$5.49
This is a classic - a Coney Island-style, fried square potato knish.
One Dozen Traditional Potato Latkes
$48.99
Price per dozen. Our potato latkes are simple, traditional potato pancakes. They're great with some Grandma Yetta's apple sauce.
Grandma Yetta's Applesauce
Price per pint. I totally ripped this recipe from my Grandma Yetta. I think she'd be proud! Not too sweet, properly chunky.... It's just kinda perfect apple sauce.
Dozen Sweet Potato & Celeriac Latkes
Price per dozen. Celery root adds some complexity to these awesome sweet potato pancakes. They're great when heated up in the oven, but unlike the traditional potato latkes, they're pretty great to eat when they're cold as well! Served best with some creme fraiche!
Dozen Gluten-Free Latkes - WE NEED 72 HOURS NOTICE
$54.88
Price per dozen. PLEASE ORDER 72 HOURS IN ADVANCE: Our traditional potato latkes made gluten-free with gluten-free matzo meal (Requires 48 hours advance order).
Potato Latke
Priced per latke. Our potato latkes are simple, traditional potato pancakes. They're great with some Grandma Yetta's apple sauce.
Sweet Potato and Celery Root Latkes
Price per latke. Celery root adds some complexity to these awesome sweet potato pancakes. They're great when heated up in the oven, but unlike the traditional potato latkes, they're pretty great to eat when they're cold as well! Served best with some creme fraiche!
16 Count Mini Blinis
Price per 16-pack. These little pancakes are the perfect (and traditional) vehicle for caviar! Gently warm them on a sheet pan in a low oven. You want them warm, not piping hot.
Vermont Creamery® Creme Fraiche
Price per 8 ounce container. Creme fraiche, the richer, French cousin to American sour cream, is a traditional accompaniment to caviar.
Smoked Trout Roe
$31.99
80 gram jar. Really special stuff, this French trout roe is smoky and the perfect topping to an oyster
Mother of Pearl Spoon
Price per mother of pearl spoon. It's highly advisable to avoid using metal spoons when serving caviar as the metal can react with the caviar causing off-putting flavours. Traditionally, mother of pearl spoons are used instead. Best to buy 1 spoon for each type of caviar you're planning to serve as to avoid mixing flavours.
French Trout Roe
Price per 80 gram jar. Smaller orbs than salmon roe, this trout roe is smooth and earthy
Keta Salmon Roe
Price per 2 oz. jar. These large eggs have a lovely salinity that just pops in your mouth
Chocolate Babka
$23.00
Seriously. This is the best traditional chocolate babka in all of New York.
Chocolate Lingonberry Rugelach
Price per half pound (About 4 pieces). We make the best rugelach in NYC. No, seriously. We combine great dark chocolate and wild-lingonberry preserves to make the lovely filling for these moist, cream cheese dough rugelach.
Cinnamon Babka
Imagine a cinnamon roll... in Jewish form.
One Black and White Cookie
Price per cookie. Like Michael Jackson, they're black, they're white, and they're a classic.
Homemade Cheeses Blintzes
$7.99
Priced by the single blintz, these fresh farmer cheese filled blintzes are substantial. We serve them with a blueberry and cream soda compote. Sounds nuts. I know. But trust me on this!
Raspberry Walnut Rugelach
Price per half pound (about 4 pieces). Our rugelach are the vey best in NYC. No kidding! We make our raspberry and walnut filling in house and stuff enough into our cream cheese dough to make a rugelach that is the furthest thing from dry. They rock!
Apricot Walnut Rugelach
Price per half pound (about 4 pieces). Our rugelach are the vey best in NYC. I'm sorry, Miss Jackson. I am for real! We make our rapricot and walnut filling in house and stuff enough into our cream cheese dough to make a rugelach that is the furthest thing from dry. They rock!
Large Torres Black Truffle Chips
4.41 oz bag. Specialty imported potato chips
Small Torres Black Truffle Chips
Specialty imported potato chips. 1.41 oz Bag
Fever-Tree Premium Club Soda
Made with soft spring water. 6.8 oz
Shelsky's $50 Gift Card
$51.00
Get the gift everyone love! Don't know what to get for a last minute gift? Shelsky's has you covered! (THIS IS A PHYSICAL GIFT CARD. Please tell us any special instructions when you order.) Add a gift card to your order.
Shelsky's $75 Gift Card
$76.00
Shelsky's $100 Gift Card
$101.00
Shelsky's $150 Gift Card
$151.00
Shelsky's $200 Gift Card
$201.00
Shelsky's $15 Gift Card
$16.00
Shelsky's $25 Gift Card
$26.00
Mcvitie's Digestives Dark Chocolate
266 g
Norwegian Baked Knekkebrød Classic
Crispbread baked with love in Brooklyn delicious, crispy, wholesome net wt 6 oz
Norwegian Baked Knekkebrød Sea Salt Flakes
Net wt 6 oz
Carr's Original Table Water Cracker
4.25 oz box
Carr's Poppy & Sesame Thin Savory Crackers
6.5 oz box
Auria's Pandan Kaya
Small batch/ made in Brooklyn 8 oz jar
Vermont Dairy Creme Fraiche
1/2 lb container
Wasabi Masago Tobiko
Price per 2 oz
Ortiz Boquerones Anchovies
New weight: 3.88 oz
Fox's U-Bet Vanilla Flavored Syrup
New wt 20 oz
Kewpie Japanese Mayonnaise
17.64 fl oz
Fox's U-Bet Chocolate Flavored Syrup
Sarson's Malt Vinegar
Great for fried food and chips 300 ml bottle
Uncle Jerry's Extra Dark Pretzels
Large bag (8 oz bog)
Uncle Jerry's Pretzels "Specials"
HP Sauce
$6.89
8.99 oz bottle
Laoganma Spicy Chili Crisp
7.41 oz jar
Auria's Hot Chilli Sambal
Joray Fruit Rolls
$2.49
Real fruit .75 oz
Joyva Chocolate Covered Marshmallow Twist
New wt 9 oz
LRG Bamba Peanut Butter Puffs
2.5oz Bag
Nestle Lion Choco Bar
50 g
Lion White Bar
60 g
Boost Bar
Milk chocolate, caramel and biscuit energy 48.5 g
Cadbury Dairy Milk Fruit & Nut
49 g
Cadbury Dairy Milk Original
45 g
Cadbury Dairy Milk Whole Nut
SML Bamba Peanut Butter Puffs
1 oz Bag
Joyva Jelly Rings Box
Net wt 9 oz
Matzo Project Matzo Ball Soup Kit
This box has everything you need to whip up a steaming pot of matzo ball soup
Large Bag Matzo Project Everything Matzo Chips
Great on the go! For a quick exodus! Crumble in soup...and put the OY in oyster cracker! NET WT 6oz
Large Bag Matzo Project Salted Matzo Chips
Small Bag Matzo Project Everything Matzo Chips
Great on the go! For a quick exodus! Crumble in soup...and put the oy in oyster cracker! Net wt 6 oz (large) 1 oz (small)
Small Bag Matzo Project Salted Matzo Chips
Matzo Project Flat Everything Matzo
Vegan, nut free, no sugar added net wt 5.5 oz
Matzo Project Flat Salted Matzo
1 lb Granola From Another Mother
Marcy's husband wanted a better breakfast cereal, and she knew she could make it happen. She developed an all-star ratio to create the perfect balance of savory and sweet. Conceived in Manhattan and baked in Brooklyn, her own brand of granola was born. Wheat-free, additive and preservative-free.
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: