Lost Borough Ice Cream

Bizcocho

Our best-seller and a tribute to Dominican birthday celebrations. This creamy, citrusy ice cream is studded with chunks of Dominican cake and ribbons of caramel, echoing the dulce de leche version of this cherished classic. Buen provecho. – Patrick

Lemon Blueberry Cake

Created for our one-year anniversary, this bright lemon ice cream features swirls of blueberry preserves and bites of iced lemon blueberry pound cake—two of my all-time favorite flavors. – Patrick

Grape-nuts

(Jam-Gra-Nut) Frozen Custard with Post Grape-Nuts Cereal

Yonkers Blackout

Rich chocolate cake layered with dark chocolate ganache, typically complemented by a hint of coffee flavor and finished with a smooth chocolate frosting.

Taro Monster

Creamy taro ice cream with a vibrant purple hue, garnished with fresh basil leaves.

Messy Girl / Strawberry Shortcake

Sweet, lovable, and just a little chaotic—our take on strawberry shortcake. A sweet cream base gets tangled up with tart strawberry preserves and chunks of buttery pound cake. A runaway favorite.

Café Bustelo

Rich, bold coffee with a smooth, robust flavor profile, crafted from finely ground beans for a deep, aromatic experience.

Fall Harvest

(Matcha-Van-Ho) Matcha Green Tea Ice Cream with Vanilla and Honey

Papi Chulo

Creamy blend of coconut, pineapple, and rum, garnished with a cherry and pineapple slice.

Cookies Cookies Cookies!

The globe-trotting, overachieving cousin of Cookies & Cream. This flavor brings together Oreos, Golden Oreos, chocolate chip cookies, and Biscoff cookies, swirled with rich chocolate and caramel syrup. It’s indulgence—multiplied.

Vanilla

Creamy vanilla ice cream scoops garnished with a fresh mint sprig and accompanied by vanilla beans.

Ice Cream Float Beverage

$12.35

Creamy ice cream floats in a fizzy soda, topped with whipped cream and a drizzle of syrup.