Full menu
16" PAPA'S PIZZA
$22.79
Thick or Thin Crust
10" PAPA'S PIZZA
$13.19
PAM'S STYLE LARGE PIZZA
Deep Dish
PAM'S STYLE JUNIOR PIZZA
$7.19
PAM'S STYLE MEDIUM PIZZA
$20.39
14" PAPA'S PIZZA
12" PAPA'S PIZZA
$16.79
VEGETARIAN CALZONE
$15.59
Pizza sauce, filled with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, tomato & mozzarella
HAWAIIAN CALZONE
Pizza sauce, filled with Canadian bacon, pineapple, tomato & mozzarella (Try it w/ our sweet BBQ sauce)
MEAT DELUXE CALZONE
Pizza sauce, filled with pepperoni, bacon, ground beef, Italian sausage & mozzarella
MAC & CHEESE CALZONE
Garlic butter & cheddar cheese sauce, filled with homemade mac & cheese, mozzarella, cheddar, sprinkled with parmesan & black pepper
BELLYBUSTER CALZONE
Pizza sauce, filled with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives & mozzarella
BUCKY SPECIAL CALZONE
Pizza sauce, filled with extra mushrooms, Italian sausage, mozzarella & cheddar
BBQ CHICKEN CALZONE
BBQ sauce, filled with mushroom, onion, chicken & mozzarella
CHICKEN RANCHER CALZONE
Ranch sauce, filled with mushroom, onion, tomato, bacon, chicken, mozzarella & cheddar
CHICKEN ALFREDO CALZONE
Alfredo sauce, filled with fresh garlic, spinach, onion, tomato, bacon, chicken & mozzarella
BUFFALO CHICKEN RANCHER CALZONE
Buffalo & ranch sauce, filled with mushroom, onion, tomato, bacon, chicken, mozzarella & cheddar
SPINACH DELIGHT CALZONE
Garlic butter sauce, filled with spinach chicken, fresh garlic, tomato, mozzarella & cheddar
MARGARITA CALZONE
Garlic butter sauce, filled with fresh garlic, spinach, tomato, oregano & mozzarella
HOT HONEY HEATER CALZONE
Pizza sauce, topped with extra pepperoni, extra mozzarella, then drizzled with our hot honey
RED HOT RANCHER
Ranch sauce, topped with onion, bacon, diced chicken, mozzarella & cheddar then drizzled with Franks red hot sauce
PAPA SMOKEY
Sweet BBQ sauce, topped with onion, bacon, diced chicken, mozzarella & cheddar then drizzled with chipotle ranch
BUILD YOUR OWN CALZONE
$10.19
Comes with pizza sauce & mozzarella, then fill it with your favorite toppings
GUTBUSTER CALZONE
Pizza sauce, filled with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, Italian sausage & mozzarella
MOZZARELLA STICKS
$9.59
7 crispy and delicious sticks made with real Wisconsin mozzarella. Served w/ our signature marinara
1 lb CHICKEN WINGS
Mixture of drummies & paddles by the pound, served naked with your choice of dipping sauce
LARGE CHEESE BREAD STICKS
$14.99
10 of our breadsticks topped with mozzarella, baked to perfection
SINGLE CHEESE CURDS
White Wisconsin cheddar cheese curds lightly dusted with a golden coating
SINGLE SPICY CHEESE CURDS
Fresh Wisconsin cheese curds deliver an authentic taste and spicy kick in every bite
LARGE BREAD STICKS
$12.59
10 freshly baked sticks, smothered with garlic butter & parmesan
SPICY CHICKEN BITES
Hot & spicy bite sized chunks of chicken. Served by 3/4 of a pound with your choice of dipping sauce
CHICKEN STRIPS
$11.99
Crispy, juicy tenderness & seasoned to perfection. Served at 10 ounces an order (3-5) with your choice of dipping sauce
SMALL BREAD STICKS
$7.79
Five freshly baked sticks, smothered with garlic butter & parmesan
LARGE FRENCH FRIES
$5.99
A fluffy, buttery potato flavor on the inside and a crisp, textered exterior
SIDE FRIES
$3.59
SMALL CHEESE BREAD STICKS
Five of our breadsticks topped with mozzarella, baked to perfection
SMALL CINNAMON STICKS
Five of our freshly baked breadsticks, smothered with butter & cinnamon sugar served w/ our homemade frosting
FRIED CHEESY RAVIOLI
Crispy, delicate pasta pocket filled with melted ricatta cheese. Served w/ our signature marinara
FRIED PICKLES
Fresh garden pickles, thick sliced in a golden breading, dusted with bits of sweet basil & hints of garlic. Served best w/ our spicy avocado ranch
PIZZA MELT
Our garlic bread, spread with pizza sauce, served with toppings of your choice & mozzarella
LARGE CINNAMON STICKS
10 of our freshly baked breadsticks, smothered with butter & cinnamon sugar served w/ our homemade frosting
DOUBLE CHEESE CURDS
$19.19
2 lb CHICKEN WINGS
$25.79
MISS VICKIES SEA SALT
$1.79
Kettle-cooked potato chips typically seasoned with sea salt, offering a crunchy texture and classic flavor.
SOUR CREAM & ONION CHIPS
Thinly sliced potato chips seasoned with sour cream and onion flavoring.
MISS VICKIES JALAPENO
Crispy kettle-cooked potato chips typically seasoned with spicy jalapeño flavor for a crunchy and zesty snack experience.
DOUBLE SPICY CHEESE CURDS
MISS VICKIE'S SPICY DILL PICKLE
Crispy chips typically infused with a tangy dill pickle flavor and a hint of spice.
CHEESE BREAD
Our garlic bread topped with mozzarella, baked to perfection
GARLIC BREAD
$4.79
Baked & smothered with garlic butter
RANCH
$0.95
Creamy ranch sauce typically includes mayonnaise, sour cream, and a blend of herbs like dill and chives, enhanced with garlic and onion powders for a classic dipping experience.
MARINARA
Marinara sauce made with tomatoes, garlic, olive oil, and herbs, offering a classic Italian dip for bread or appetizers.
GARLIC BUTTER
Garlic butter typically features a blend of creamy butter and aromatic garlic, often enhanced with herbs, providing a rich and savory dipping experience.
CHIPOTLE RANCH
Chipotle ranch combines smoky chipotle peppers with creamy buttermilk ranch, typically featuring a hint of lemon for a zesty and rich dipping experience.
BBQ SAUCE
A smoky and tangy condiment, this BBQ sauce typically includes flavors that complement grilled meats and finger foods.
FRANKS RED HOT
A classic hot sauce typically featuring aged cayenne peppers, vinegar, and garlic. Ideal for adding a spicy kick to your favorite dishes.
FLAMING HONEY GARLIC
A blend of honey and garlic with a touch of heat, offering a sweet and spicy flavor profile for dipping.
PIZZA SAUCE
Made from vine-ripened Italian tomatoes, this classic pizza sauce typically features garlic and a blend of herbs for a rich, traditional flavor.
SOUR CREAM
A creamy base of sour cream, often used as a versatile dipping sauce or condiment.
TACO SAUCE
A zesty blend of tomatoes, onions, and spices, typically enhanced with garlic and chili for a flavorful dipping experience.
HOT HONEY
Honey infused with chili flakes, offering a balance of sweetness and heat. Ideal for drizzling or dipping.
GARLIC PARMESAN
Creamy sauce with grated parmesan cheese and crushed garlic, speckled with herbs.
BLUE CHEESE
A creamy, tangy blue cheese dipping sauce, typically enriched with garlic and rich buttermilk, ideal for enhancing various dishes.
SPICY AVOCADO RANCH
Creamy ranch blended with ripe avocado and a hint of spice, typically featuring herbs and garlic for a smooth and zesty dipping experience.
VANILLA FROSTING
Vanilla frosting typically features a creamy blend of butter, sugar, and vanilla extract, providing a smooth and sweet complement for dipping.
ZESTY DIJON BBQ
A tangy blend of Dijon mustard and barbecue sauce, offering a zesty twist typically enjoyed with grilled meats and finger foods.
NACHO CHEESE
Creamy nacho cheese sauce, typically featuring a hint of jalapeño peppers, ideal for dipping or drizzling.
HONEY MUSTARD
A harmonious blend of sweet honey and tangy mustard, this versatile dipping sauce enhances the flavors of various dishes.
# 5 CLUB SUB
Hoagie topped with ham, turkey, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
# 9 PAPA'S SPECIAL SUB
$11.39
Toasted hoagie topped with italian beef, mozzarella, marinara, green pepper & onion
# 8 BLT SUB
Toasted hoagie topped with bacon, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, black pepper & oregano
# 4 MEATBALL SUB
Toasted hoagie filled with meatballs, mozzarella, marinara, green pepper & onion
# 6 ITALIAN SALAMI & CAPICOLLO SUB
Hoagie topped with salami, capicola, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
# 7 VEGETARIAN SUB
Hoagie topped with mushroom, black olive, green pepper, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
# 3 TUNA SUB
Hoagie topped with tuna, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
# 10 CHICAGO ITALIAN BEEF SUB
Toasted hoagie topped with italian beef, provolone, garlic butter, sauteed onions & peppers. Served w/ a side of au jus sauce & giardiniera
# 11 TOASTED CHICKEN SUB
Toasted hoagie topped with diced chicken, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
#12 CHICKEN BACON RANCHER SUB
Toasted hoagie topped with diced chicken, bacon, provolone, ranch, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
# 2 TURKEY SUB
Hoagie topped with turkey, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
# 1 HAM SUB
Hoagie topped with ham, provolone, mayo, lettuce, tomato, onion, black pepper & oregano
CHEESE RAVIOLI
Six jumbo pieces smothered in our signature marinara sauce
MAC & CHEESE
Our signature homemade macaroni & cheese
BAKED SPAGHETTI
Our spaghetti topped with mozzarella then baked to perfection
SPAGHETTI
$10.79
Classic spaghetti noodles covered in our signature marinara sauce
SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS
Classic spaghetti noodles & five meatballs covered in our signature marinara sauce
BAKED SPAGHETTI W/ MEATBALLS
Our spaghetti & meatballs topped with mozzarella then baked to perfection
BAKED MAC & CHEESE
Our signature mac & cheese topped with mozzarella, baked to perfection
HOMEMADE LASAGNA
$14.39
Ribbon noodles with italian sausage, veggies & a four cheese blend, smothered in our signature marinara
BEEF RAVIOLI
SMALL SALAD
$8.39
Served with tomato, onion, black olive, mushroom, green pepper & cheddar cheese. Add any meat for additional charge
LARGE SALAD
MACKINAC ISLAND FUDGE
$9.30
(Pint) Sweet vanilla ice cream with a melt-in-your-mouth chocolate fudge ripple and chunks of rich chocolate fudge
TURTLE
(Pint) Classic vanilla ice cream with swirls of rich chocolate fudge and gooey caramel, bunches of lightly roasted and salted pecans
THIS JUST GOT SERIOUS
(Pint) Salted caramel ice cream folded woth sea salt chocolate fudge and roasted cashews
PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE DOUGH
(Pint) Vanilla ice cream loaded with soft cookie dough chunks, rich chocolate chip flakes and a thick peanut butter ripple
COTTON CANDY TWIST
(Pint) Blue and pink cotton candy ice creams spun together for that whimsical carnival sensation
ZOREO
(Pint) Fudge-like Zanzibar chocolate ice cream swirled with gooey marshmellow, Oreos and bittersweet chocolate chunks
MINT CHIP
(Pint) Classic, fresh mint ice cream loaded with melt-in-your-mouth, rich chocolate flakes
COOKIE DOUGH
(Pint) Sweet cookie-flavored ice cream with heaps of soft chocolate chip cookie dough chunks and tons of rich chocolate chips
BLUE MOON
(Pint) Just like the milk in the bottom of a Fruit Loops bowl with a wacky blue color
BUTTER PECAN
(Pint) Buttery pecan ice cream with boat-loads of crisp, lightly roasted and salted pecans
COCONUT ALMOND BLISS
(Pint) Tropical coconut-flavored ice cream with tons of melt-in-your-mouth chocolate flakes and crispy almond flakes
HEAPS OF LOVE
(Pint) Anything and everything you can want! Oreos, brownies, cookie dough, pecans, caramel and chocolate ripplies all packed into vanilla ice cream
MINT AVALANCHE
(Pint) Fresh mint ice cream loaded with Andes Candies and Grasshopper cookies spun off with a chocolate fudge swirl
ULTIMATE OREO
(Pint) Scrumptous Oreo ice cream made with boat-loads of whole Oreos
ZANZIBAR CHOCOLATE
(Pint) All-natural and award-winning chocolate ice cream made with three kinds of cocoa for a rich, fudge brownie taste
PEANUT BUTTER CUP
(Pint) Smooth chocolate ice cream brimming with mouthwatering peanut butter ripples and rich peanut butter cups
RASBERRY RHASODY
(Pint)
SUPERMAN
(Pint) Meet your kryptonite... Cherry, Blue Moon and Vanilla ice creams combine forces to bring you one super scoop
BLACKBERRY LEMON BAR
EXHAUSTED PARENT
(Pint) Bourbon-spiked expresso oreo ice cream swirled with bittersweet chocolate chunks
ICED LATTE-DA
(Pint) Fantastic Wisconsin-made caffeinated expresso ice cream with a fudge swirl and chocolate chunks
KITTY KITTY BANG BANG
(Pint) Rich cheesecake ice cream folded with Oreos, chocolate chunks and a tart raspberry ripple
BLACK CHERRY OAT CREAM
(Pint) Delectably sweet black cherry non-dairy frozen dessert busting with whole black cherries
ESPRESSO ALMOND FUDGE
Espresso ice cream swirled with thick chocolate fudge and crunchy praline almonds
KIWI ITALIAN ICE
Bright vegan, kiwi italian ice with poppy seeds and natural dyes, tastes like sunshine-in-a-cup.
CHOCOLATE CHIP OATMEAL COOKIE
Brown sugar, cinnamon and vanilla vegan oat cream, mixed with oatmeal cookie dough, chocolate and roasted pecans
CHOCOLATE
DUTCH MAID VANILLA
(Pint) Sweet, classic and all-natural made with Wisconsin cream
$17.40
(Quart) Vanilla ice cream loaded with soft cookie dough chunks, rich chocolate chip flakes and a thick peanut butter ripple
(Quart) Sweet cookie-flavored ice cream with heaps of soft chocolate chip cookie dough chunks and tons of rich chocolate chips
(Quart) Scrumptous Oreo ice cream made with boat-loads of whole Oreos
(Quart) Fudge-like Zanzibar chocolate ice cream swirled with gooey marshmellow, Oreos and bittersweet chocolate chunks
(Quart) Just like the milk in the bottom of a Fruit Loops bowl with a wacky blue color
(Quart) Buttery pecan ice cream with boat-loads of crisp, lightly roasted and salted pecans
(Quart) Blue and pink cotton candy ice creams spun together for that whimsical carnival sensation
(Quart) Anything and everything you can want! Oreos, brownies, cookie dough, pecans, caramel and chocolate ripplies all packed into vanilla ice cream
(Quart) Classic vanilla ice cream with swirls of rich chocolate fudge and gooey caramel, bunches of lightly roasted and salted pecans
(Quart)
(Quart) Sweet, classic and all-natural made with Wisconsin cream
STRAWBERRY SHAKE
$9.60
Fresh and creamy blend of ripe strawberries, served chilled with a delightful milk base.
SPECIALTY SHAKE
$10.20
Your favorite flavor blended into a shake
TWISTER
Vanilla ice cream mixed with your favorite candy
VANILLA SHAKE
Creamy Vanilla Milkshake, Smooth and Classic
CHOCOLATE SHAKE
Velvety Chocolate Milkshake, Blended to Perfection
3 COOKIES
$2.40
Homemade chocolate chip cookies, typically baked in-house, offering a classic treat with rich chocolate chips.
COOKIE
$0.90
Deliciously baked, classic sweet treat perfect with milk or coffee.
BLUE MOON SANDWICH
$6.90
Blue Moon ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
ROLLED COOKIE DOUGH SANDWICH
$7.74
Cookie Dough ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies, rolled in chocolate chips
VANILLA SANDWICH
Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
HEAPS OF LOVE SANDWICH
Heaps of love ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
ULTIMATE OREO SANDWICH
Ultimate Oreo ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
ROLLED PB COOKIE DOUGH SANDWICH
Peanut butter cookie dough ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies, rolled in chocolate chips
ROLLED BLUE MOON SANDWICH
Blue Moon ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies, rolled in sprinkles
ROLLED ULTIMATE OREO SANDWICH
Ultimate Oreo ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies, rolled in chocolate chips
ROLLED MINT CHIP SANDWICH
Mint Chip ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies, rolled in chocolate chips
SPRINKLE VANILLA SANDWICH
Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies, rolled in sprinkles
BUTTER PECAN SANDWICH
Butter pecan ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
PB COOKIE DOUGH SANDWICH
PB Cookie Dough ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
COOKIE DOUGH SANDWICH
Cookie Dough ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
CHOCOLATE CHIP VANILLA SANDWICH
Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies, rolled in chocolate chips
3 MINT CHIP SANDWICHES
(3) Mint Chip ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
3 ULTIMATE OREO SANDWICHES
(3) Ultimate Oreo ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
3 HEAPS OF LOVE SANDWICHES
(3) Heaps of love ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
3 VANILLA SANDWICHES
(3) Dutch Maid Vanilla ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
3 COOKIE DOUGH SANDWICHES
(3) Cookie Dough ice cream squished between two of our chocolate chip cookies
20oz
20oz sodas including Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, and Mountain Dew.
PURE LEAF
Choice of lemon or sweet tea from Pure Leaf. Classic beverage option.
BUBBL'R
$2.75
Refreshing bubble tea with options like blood orange, pomegranate acai, and triple berry flavored BUBBL'R.
SPORT TOP WATER BOTTLE
$2.99
A convenient sport top water bottle, offering pure and refreshing water to keep you hydrated and revitalized during your active lifestyle.
2 LITER
Choice of 2-liter sodas, including regular and diet options.
CAN
$1.91
Variety of canned sodas, including Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, and more.
Is this your restaurant?
Send us your menu — a photo, a PDF or a link — and we will publish it on this page: